Original Research Article
Accuracy of Shukla’s formula for depth of insertion of umbilical venous catheter
Department of Paediatrics, NRI Medical College and Superspeciality Hospital, Chinakakani, Mangalagiri, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh, India
Received: 26 February 2023
Revised: 11 March 2023
Accepted: 13 March 2023
*Correspondence:
Dr. Vegesna Dedeepya,
E-mail: dedeepyavegesna01996@gmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: The use of umbilical venous catheter (UVC) is an essential part of neonatal care allowing delivery of intravenous fluids, nutrition, and medication. It is important to know the position of the UVC tip accurately at the first attempt to prevent complications and minimize handling. We aimed to determine the precision and accuracy of Shukla’s formula developed to guide UVC placement and to evaluate the probability of UVC placement at desired radiological markings using weight-based Shukla’s formula.
Methods: This study was carried out at NICU in NRI medical college, a tertiary care center in Chinakakani, Andhra Pradesh, India. A prospective observational study was done from December of 2021 to September 2022. With an aim to study the accuracy of Shukla's formula in assessing the depth of insertion of UVC, depth was calculated and position of the tip of the catheter confirmed by x-ray.
Results: We have taken 138 neonates in our NICU unit with mean gestational age of 33.91 wks. and with mean birth weight of 1.91 kg. Out of 138 infants 99 had a successful ideal UVC placement using Shukla's formula. In reference to gestational age out 83 newborns in gestational age between 32-36 weeks 62 had ideal placement of UVC. In reference to birth weight ideal position of the UVC was seen in 73% of newborns.
Conclusions: Shukla’s formula provided a reasonably accurate probability of achieving ideal UVC position in most of our babies: accurate in 72%.
Keywords: UVC, Shukla's formula, Depth of insertion, NICU, UVC
INTRODUCTION
Umbilical venous catheter (UVC) placement is a common neonatal procedure. The use of UVC is an essential part of neonatal care allowing delivery of intravenous fluids, nutrition, and medication. An UAC allows blood to be taken from an infant at different times, without repeated needle sticks. It can also be used to continuously monitor a baby's blood pressure. An UVC allows fluids and medicines to be given without frequently replacing an intravenous (IV) line.1
Indications for insertion of UVC are: central venous access for low-birth-weight infants to avoid multiple peripheral cannulations, delivery of drugs and parenteral nutrition, emergency vascular access for resuscitation of infants at birth, exchange transfusion.2 Few of the contraindications are: Abnormalities of the abdominal wall, necrotising enterocolitis, peritonitis. Complications which we may be due to UVC catheterization: sepsis, embolism, venous thrombosis, pericardial effusion, pleural effusion, portal hypertension, displacement leading to blood loss, breakage of catheter on removal, intra-abdominal extravasation.2-9
It is important to position the UVC tip accurately at the first attempt to prevent complications and minimise handling. Catheters positioned too low need to be removed, but catheters positioned too high may be withdrawn in a sterile fashion to a safe position. We aimed to determine the precision and accuracy of Shukla’s formula developed to guide UVC placement.
Depth of insertion of UVC is generally calculated either by using surface markings/ BW of baby. Some well-known internationally used formulas are: Using surface markings: 1. Dunn method using vertical shoulder-umbilical distance (Dunn vertical), 2. Dunn method using diagonal shoulder-umbilical distance (Dunn diagonal), 3. Umbilical to nipple distance-1 cm (UN-1) and 4. Umbilical to inter mammary distance (UIMD). Using birth weight (BW): 1. ((BW×3+9)/2) +1 (Shukla’s method) and 2. (BW×3+9)/2 (Modified Shukla).10-14
Aim of the study was to evaluate the probability of UVC placement at desired radiological markings using weight-based Shukla’s formula.
METHOD
Study place
This study was carried out at NICU in NRI medical college, a tertiary care center in Chinakakani, city of Andhra Pradesh, India.
Study design and period
A prospective observational study was done from December of 2021 to September 2022.
Selection criteria
All the neonates admitted to our NICU unit during the above period requiring UVC. All babies with congenital anomalies affecting thorax or abdomen and babies with skeletal dysplasia are excluded to maintain uniformity.
Study size
A total of 138 neonates admitted to our NICU unit required UVC insertion.
Procedure
Formula was used to calculate the UVC placement depth. Then catheter tip localization was done and confirmed radiologically by x rays. X-rays were taken both in anteroposterior view and lateral view.15 Theoretical positions using formulae were compared with actual measurements on the x ray were then classified as ideal, high, low or malposition by T9-T10 method.16 Ideal position of UVC was when the tip of the catheter was at the upper border of T9 to lower border of T10. High position was when the catheter tip was above upper border of T9. Low is when the tip is below lower border of T10. Catheter tip was said to be mal positioned anywhere else apart from IVC of ductus venosus.
Mothers were interviewed for relevant data which was recorded in a predetermined forum. Data were collected for following variables: gestational age, birth weight, UVC depth as calculated by Shukla’s formula, Gender of baby, SGA or AGA, location of tip as seen in radiological studies. Then mean and standard deviation were calculated depending on underlying distribution of the data. A prospective observational study was done. Probability of achieving ideal UVC position in the neonates were calculated. Probability of ideal position in reference to different variables were calculated. Results were compared with previous studies.
RESULTS
Ideal position of UVC
The 99 out of 138 newborns requiring UVC placement whose depth of insertion was calculated by Shukla’s formula born and confirmed by the position of catheter tip on x-ray was at ideal position which is 72% i.e., majority of the newborns who were catheterized.
Ideal position vs gender
Out of 56 females, UVC was in ideal position in 41 i.e., 73.2%. And out of 82 males, UVC was in ideal position in 58 i.e., 70.7%. Hence, our study showed no significant difference in position of the UVC tip in reference to gender.
Ideal position vs gestational age
Out of 83 infants in gestational weeks 32 to 36 weeks, 62 had ideal UVC placement i.e., 75%.
Ideal position vs birth weight
In infants with birth weight between 1500 gm and 2500 gm ideal position of the UVC was seen in around 73% newborns.
DISCUSSION
Shukla’s formula provided a reasonably accurate probability of achieving ideal UVC position in most of our babies: accurate in 72% with our median gestational age and weight were 33.91(27-40) weeks and 1.92 (0.620-4.20) kg compared to study done by Wei which had accuracy of 52.9% by using weight-based Shukla’s formula. According to Lean et al of 118 eligible infants, 70 had the UVC tip in a position where measurements could be used. Their median (IQR) gestational age and weight were 28.5 (26-36) weeks and 1035 (745-2788) gm, respectively. A formula based on birth weight had the highest rate of correct position (52.9%).17
Risk of over insertion is less in our study 9.4%, when compared with Wei et al which is about 42.9% and according to Gomella et at where over insertion with Shukla’s formula is 73%.14,17 Low position in our study is high 19%, as compared to 1% according to Wei et al and 4.3% according to Gomella et al.14,17
The two most commonly used methods to predict the accurate depth of UVCS are the method of Dunn (based on measurement of the shoulder umbilicus length) and the method of Shukla.10-13 According to Ayman, the probability of inserting ideal position of UVC by birth weight-based Shukla’s formula (32.9%) is same as by surface marking method (40.2%).18
In a study conducted exclusively in pre-terms by Akar et al where UVC length was calculated using Shukla’s formula, length of the catheter calculated according to the Shukla formula was intracardiac in 88.2% of premature infants.19
According to Shareef et al who compared Dunn’s method using surface markings with Shukla’s formula using birth weight. Dunn’s method was more accurate than Shukla’s method for determining the optimal insertion length of UVCs (45% vs. 25%, p=0.04); especially in infants with birth weight <1500 gm (59% vs. 11%, p=0.00296). Whereas, a significantly higher rate of highly positioned catheter tips was demonstrated in Shukla's method than in Dunn's method (73% vs. 51%, p=0.0264); and especially in infants with birth weight <1500 gm (89% vs. 35%, p=0.00104). This study showed that Dunn’s method resulted in a higher rate of ideal insertion length of UVCs than Shukla’s method. The rate of correctly positioned catheter tip was significantly high in Dunn’s method especially in infants with birth weight <1500 gm. whereas, the rate of highly positioned catheter tip was significantly high in Shukla’s method particularly in infants with birth weight <1500 gm.20
Gupta et al. conducted in 2015 and observational study compared Shukla's formula with other four morphometric measurements at varying birth weights and reported that in infants with birth weights ≤ 1500 gm, Shukla's formula resulted in (46%) correctly positioned UVC tips which is significantly higher than that observed in our study and (49%) catheter tips that positioned at high levels, a result which is significantly lower than the present study.21
Given the limited reliability of chest X-ray in determining the correct position of UVCs, ultrasonography should become one of the routine skills of all caregivers in neonatal wards involved in the placement of umbilical catheters. Specialists practicing in neonatal intensive care units could improve themselves and evaluate UVC with echocardiography, making this a routine part of clinical practice. Echocardiography-guided fixation of the catheter will reduce the complications related to catheter malposition.
CONCLUSION
Shukla’s formula provided a reasonably accurate probability of achieving ideal UVC position in most of our babies: accurate in 72%.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
- 1. Santillanes G, Claudius I. Pediatric vascular access and blood sampling techniques. In: Roberts JR, Custalow CB, Thomsen TW, eds. Roberts and Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine and Acute Care. 7th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier. 2019;19.
- 2. MacDonald MG. Umbilical vein catheterisation. Ch 28. In: MacDonald MG, Ramasethu J. Atlas of procedures in neonatology. 3rd Ed. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. Philadelphia. 2002.
- 3. British Association of Perinatal Medicine. Use of Central Venous Catheters in Neonates A Framework for Practice. Revised 2018. London: BAPM. 2015. Available at: http://www.bapm.org/publications/documents/guidelines/BAPM%20CVC%20final%20Dec15.pdf. Accessed on 21st August 2022.
- 4. Landers S, Moise AA, Fraley JK, Smith EO, Baker CJ. Factors associated with umbilical catheter-related sepsis in neonates. American Journal of Disease in Childhood. 1991;145(6):675-80.
- 5. Lam HS, Li AM, Chu WC, Yeung CK, Fok TF, Ng PC. Mal-positioned umbilical venous catheter causing liver abscess in a preterm neonate. Biology of the Neonate. 2005;88(1):54-6.
- 6. Kim JH, Lee YS, Kim SH, Lee SK, Lim MK, Kim HS. Does umbilical vein catheterization lead to portal venous thrombosis? Prospective US evaluation in 100 neonates. Radiology. 2001;219:645-650.
- 7. Sehgal A, Cook V, Dunn M. Pericardial effusion associate with an appropriately placed umbilical venous catheter. J Perinatol. 2007;27(5):317-9.
- 8. Department of Health. Review of the deaths of four babies due to cardiac tamponade associated with the presence of a central venous catheter. Department of Health, London. 2001. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/nzc7wlx. Accessed on 10 April 2022.
- 9. Pabalan MJ, Wynn RJ, Reynolds AM, Ryan RM, Youssfi M, Manja V et al. Pleural effusion with parenteral nutrition solution: an unisial complication of an “appropriately” placed umbilical venous catheter. Am J Perinatol. 2007;24(10):581-5.
- 10. Dunn PM. Localization of the umbilical catheter by post-mortem measurement. Arch Dis Child. 1966;41(215):69-75.
- 11. Lopriore E, Verheij GH, Walther FJ. Measurement of the 'shoulder-umbilical' distance for insertion of umbilical catheters in newborn babies: questionnaire study. Neonatology. 2008;94(1):35-7.
- 12. Ford S, Hagan J. Using surface anatomy measurements to place umbilical catheters. J Perinatol. 2016;36:161-2.
- 13. Shukla H, Ferrara A. Rapid estimation of insertional length of umbilical catheters in newborns. Am J Dis Child. 1986;140(8):786-8.
- 14. Verheij GH, Pas AB, Smits-Wintjens VEHJ. Revised formula to determine the insertion length of umbilical vein catheters. Eur J Pediatr. 2013;172:1011-5.
- 15. Baker DH, Berdon WE, James LS. Proper localization of umbilical arterial and venous catheters by lateral roentgenograms. Pediatrics. 1969;43:34-9.
- 16. Fleming SE, Kim JH. Ultrasound-guided umbilical catheter insertion in neonates. J Perinatol. 2011;31:344-9.
- 17. Gomella TL, Cunningham MD, Eyal FG. Neonatology, management, procedures, on-call problems, diseases and drugs. 5th edn. Lange Medical books/ McGraw-Hill. 2005.
- 18. Lean WL, Dawson JA, Davis PG, Theda C, Thio M. Accuracy of five formulae to determine the insertion length of umbilical venous catheters. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2019;104(2):F165-9.
- 19. Sheta A, Kamaluddeen M, Soraisham AS. Umbilical venous catheter insertion depth estimation using birth weight versus surface measurement formula: a randomized controlled trial. J Perinatol. 2020;40(4):567-72.
- 20. Akar S, Dincer E, Topcuoğlu S, Yavuz T, Akay H, Gokmen T et al. Determination of Accurate Position of Umbilical Venous Catheters in Premature Infants. Am J Perinatol. 2022;39(4):369-72.
- 21. Shareef AA, Mohammed RF, Kandla NA. Assessment of umbilical venous catheter insertion depth using Dunn and Shukla method. Curr Pediatr Res 2021;25(8):852-7.
- 22. Gupta AO, Peesay MR, Ramasethu J. Simple measurements to place umbilical catheters using surface anatomy. J Perinatol. 2015;35(7):476-80.