Original Research Article
Comparison of clinical profile between Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium falciparum malaria in children in tertiary care hospital
Department of Pediatrics, Niloufer Hospital, Osmania Medical College, Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Received: 19 May 2018
Revised: 29 May 2018
Accepted: 02 June 2018
*Correspondence:
Dr. Shabbeer Ahmed,
E-mail: drshabeer1@gmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: The high prevalence of uncomplicated malaria as seen in this study suggests the importance of timely diagnosis and effective treatment and encourages new activities to further decrease complicated malaria cases.
Methods: In this study, malaria was diagnosed by conventional thick and thin peripheral smear stained with Leishman stain, examined under oil immersion. The slide was considered negative when there were no parasites in 100 HPF. Rapid diagnostic tests were based on detection of specific plasmodium antigen, LDH (optimal test) for Vivax and HRP2 for falciparum. The mode of presentations like fever, splenomegaly, vomiting, abdominal pain, laboratory investigations and complications were noted. Simple malaria was defined as Plasmodium vivax or Plasmodium falciparum malaria without any complications. All the statistical analysis was done by using SPSS 16 version and in MS Excel. Qualitative variables were expressed as frequencies and percentages. Chi-square was used for examining the categorical data.
Results: A total 100 cases of malaria diagnosed by rapid diagnostic test and/or peripheral smear were studied. 69% of the cases were falciparum malaria and 31% of the cases were vivax malaria. Males were more commonly affected than females. Vivax malaria was most common between 5-10 years of age and falciparum malaria was more common in 0-5 years of age. Uncomplicated malaria was seen in 73% of the cases and complicated malaria was seen in 27% of the cases. Incidence of complicated malaria was more common in case of falciparum malaria. Fever, pallor, hepatomegaly and splenomegaly were significant for clinical diagnosis of malaria. Severe anaemia was the most common presentation of complicated malaria followed by jaundice. Cerebral malaria was more common in case of falciparum malaria. Metabolic acidosis and renal failure were more common in falciparum malaria. Hypoglycemia, significant bleeding and shock were more common in falciparum malaria. ARDS was most common in vivax malaria.
Conclusions: This study emphasizes the importance of severity of P. Vivax malaria and recommends further studies to establish mortality and severity predictors specific to it.
Keywords: Clinical profile, Children, Malaria, Plasmodium vivax, Plasmodium falciparum, Tertiary care hospital
INTRODUCTION
India contributes to about 2/3rd of Malaria in the South East Asia region.1 There exists heterogeneity and variability in the transmission between and within the states of the country as many ecotypes of Malaria have been recognized. Among the four species of Plasmodium, Plasmodium falciparum and vivax are commonly found in India. Disease caused by Plasmodium vivax malaria used to be called benign tertian. In contrast Plasmodium falciparum causes severe malaria and often produces multi-organ failure unless treated early with multiple drugs. Kochar etal in a study reported several cases of vivax Malaria with multi-organ dysfunction syndrome.2 Profound thrombocytopenia is a common complication of falciparum malaria but recently there have been several reports of vivax malaria with thrombocytopenia.3 Acute respiratory distress syndrome, hepatic involvement and renal involvement are common in Plasmodium falciparum malaria; these complications also have been reported in Plasmodium vivax malaria4. Morbidity and mortality of Plasmodium vivax have increased recently due to the serious complications associated with it. The classic attack of malaria is recognized by its periodicity and pattern. However, today the classic clinical picture is more of an exception than the rule particularly with falciparum infection, which explains why it can easily be mistaken for other diseases with catastrophic results.
METHODS
This is a hospital based prospective observational study carried out at Niloufer hospital for women and children, Hyderabad from August 2016-July 2017 on 100 children admitted in Niloufer hospital.
Inclusion criteria
All the slide positive and/or rapid diagnostic test positive confirmed cases of malaria upto 12 years were included.
Exclusion criteria
- • Patients presented with fever but empirically treated for malaria.
- • Mixed infection of Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium falciparum malaria.
- • Patients presented with clinical features mimicking malaria like dengue fever, sepsis and meningitis.
In this study, malaria was diagnosed by conventional thick and thin peripheral smear stained with Leishman stain, examined under oil immersion.
The slide was considered negative when there were no parasites in 100 HPF. Rapid diagnostic tests were based on detection of specific plasmodium antigen, LDH (optimal test) for Vivax and HRP2 for falciparum. The mode of presentations like fever, splenomegaly, vomitings, abdominal pain, laboratory investigations and complications were noted. Simple malaria was defined as Plasmodium vivax or Plasmodium falciparum malaria without any complications.
Impaired consciousness/coma, Renal failure (serum creatinine >3 mg/dl), Jaundice (serum bilirubin >3 mg/dl), Severe anaemia (Hb <4 gm/dl),), Metabolic acidosis, Circulatory collapse/shock (systolic BP <80mm Hg, 106 0F or >420C), Hyperparasitemia (>5% parasitized RBCs), Hypoglycaemia, Significant bleeding. Thrombocytopenia in the study is defined as platelet count less than 1.5 Lakhs. In the study, reticulocyte count is taken as low when <0.5 %, normal when 0.5 -2%, high when more than 2%. The clinical profile was compared between Plasmodium vivax and Falciparum malaria. All the statistical analysis was done by using SPSS 16 version and in MS Excel. Qualitative variables were expressed as frequencies and percentages. Chi-square was used for examining the categorical data.
RESULTS
The study was conducted in Niloufer hospital, Osmania medical college, Hyderabad, during the period of August 2016 to July 2017. 100 children with P. vivax or P. falciparum with smear positive and/or rapid diagnostic test were included in the study.
Results are tabulated as presence of variable as positive (P), absence of variable as negative (N).
Table 1 shows complicated malaria is more common in falciparum malaria when compared to the vivax malaria with a significant P value (<0.05). Total Plasmodium vivax cases were 31, Of which 4 were of complicated malaria and 27 of uncomplicated malaria and Plasmodium falciparum cases were 69 , out of which 23 cases were complicated malaria and 46 cases were uncomplicated malaria.
Table 2 shows all the cases in the present study has fever. Out of 31 cases of vivax malaria, vomiting was present in 19 cases (61.3%) and in falciparum malaria, vomiting was present in 41 cases (59.4%). The P value was found to be 0.86. Vomiting were more common in cases of vivax malaria.
Table 3 shows out of 31 cases of vivax malaria, abdominal pain was present in 02 cases (6.5%) and in falciparum malaria, abdominal pain was present in 07 cases (10.1%). P value was calculated to be 0.551. Here the abdominal pain was more frequent in cases of falciparum malaria.
Table 4 shows pallor is significant finding in both falciparum malaria (72.4%) and vivax malaria (70.9%). There is only a slight difference between the cases of vivax and falciparum. The P value here is 0.87.
Table 5 shows hepatomegaly was present in 15 cases (48.4 %) out of 31 cases of vivax malaria and in 50 cases (72.5 %) out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria with significant P value (<0.05). Hepatomegaly is more common in subjects of vivax malaria, which is statistically significant.
Table 6 shows splenomegaly was present in 28 cases (90.4%) out of 31 cases of vivax malaria and in 66 cases (95.66%) out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria. P value was recorded to be 0.093. Only a slight variation of frequency of occurrence can be noted between the cases of vivax malaria and falciparum malaria.
Table 7 shows out of 31 cases of vivax malaria, cerebral malaria was present in 01 cases (3.2%) and in falciparum malaria, cerebral malaria was present in 03 cases (4.3%). The P value was calculated to be 0.791. There is no statistically significant difference in the incidence of cerebral malaria.
Table 8 shows out of 31 cases of vivax malaria, severe anaemia was present in 03 cases (9.7%) and in falciparum malaria, severe anaemia was present in 11 cases (15.9%).
P value was found to be 0.404. There is a considerable variation of frequency of severe anemia, however statistically not significant.
Table 9 shows out of 31 cases of vivax malaria, jaundice was present in 02 cases (6.5%) and in falciparum malaria, jaundice was present in 10 cases (14.5%). P value was calculated to be 0.252. Jaundice was more common in the subjects of falciparum malaria as shown in the records, though statistically not significant.
Table 10 shows thrombocytopenia was present in 16 cases (51.6%) out of 31 cases of vivax malaria and in 29 cases (42%) out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria. P value was calculated to be 0.373. Thrombocytopenia was more prevalent among the cases of vivax malaria, though statistically not significant..
Table 11 shows acidosis was present in 02 cases (2.9%) out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria. P value was calculated to be 0.338. Acidosis was not at all observed in cases of vivax malaria. Whereas on the contrary, 2 cases were positive out of 67 cases of falciparum malaria.
Table 12 shows hypoglycaemia was present in 01 cases (1.4%) out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria. P value was calculated to be 0.501. Vivax subjects showed no incidence of hypoglycemia whereas a single case out of 68 cases of falciparum malaria had hypoglycaemia.
Table 13 shows renal failure was present in 02 cases (2.9%) out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria. P value was calculated to be 0.338. All the cases of vivax malaria were negative for renal failure, whereas only 2 cases of 67 cases were positive for renal failure investigation.
Table 14 shows ARDS was present in 01 cases (3.2%) out of 31 cases of vivax malaria. Falciparum cases showed no incidence of ARDS where as a single case of vivax malaria had ARDS. P value was calculated to be 0.134.
Out of 69 cases of falciparum malaria, normal reticulocyte count was observed in 36 cases (52.19%), high reticulocyte count was observed in 21 cases (30.42%), low reticulocyte count was observed in 12 cases (17.39%). Out of 31 cases of vivax malaria, normal reticulocyte count was observed in 18 cases (58%), high reticulocyte count was observed in 4 cases (13%), low reticulocyte count was observed in 9 cases (29%).
0-Low Reticulocyte count (<0.5%), - Normal Reticulocyte count (0.5-2%), 2-High Reticulocyte count (>2%).
DISCUSSION
P. vivax malaria has been considered to be a benign form of malaria, with low mortality but studies from across the world now have shown that vivax is not benign but has been associated with complications and mortality similar to present study which also shown this trend. In the present study, the most common species to cause malaria was Plasmodium falciparum (69%) followed by Plasmodium vivax (31%). In the study of Verma et al falciparum was most common form (53.6%), vivax (27.3%), followed by mixed parasitemia (18.9%) which is similar to present findings.4 In the study of Rao P done in southern india, Plasmodium falciparum is the most frequent implicating species accounting for 64% of cases which is similar to the present study.5 But, in the study of Sonawane VB et al, the most common species to cause malaria was P. vivax (63.20%) followed by P. falciparum (20.75%) and mixed parasitemia (1.88%) which is against to the present study.6 Falciparum malaria is more common than the vivax malaria in the present study because the incidence of falciparum malaria is more common in south india compared to north india as per NVBDCP.7
In falciparum 23 (33.33%) cases were of severe malaria while 46 (67.7%) were non-severe. In vivax group 4 (12.9%) patients suffered from severe malaria and rest 27 (87.9%) were non-severe. When these results were compared statistically the p value was found to be 0.3 signifying no statistical difference between the falciparum and vivax
Cerebral malaria has been observed in 3.2% of P. vivax and 4.3 % of P. falciparum cases in present study. Cerebral malaria is a very severe complication and leading to one of the most common causes of mortality of malaria. Though exact pathogenesis of cerebral malaria in P. vivax remains unknown, few studies suggested that it might be due to sequestration and cytokine mediated cerebral injuries. Severe anaemia is the most common presentation of complicated malaria in the present study. Severe anaemia is more common in falciparum malaria when compared to the vivax malaria which is similar to the study done by Sonawaneet VB et al.8 It has been well established that the primary target of human plasmodium species is the RBCs. P. vivax has a very strong predilection for RBCs, particularly reticulocytes, whereas P. falciparum has only a moderate predilection. Like in P. falciparum, the continued presence of vivax parasites may have been sufficient to infect and destroy most of the new reticulocytes, thereby hindering the timely restoration of the erythrocytes population and this could (partly) lead to extreme anaemia over a period of several months. Moreover, there could have been compounding factors like the impaired immune response of P. vivax-infected patients as a result of recrudescence, reinfection, and relapse.
Jaundice in malaria results from hemolysis of both parasitized and non-parasitized red cells as well as malarial hepatitis. Raised liver enzymes occur because of injury to hepatocyte and cholestasis. In the present study, a total bilirubin of more than 3 mg/dl was seen in 6.4% of vivax malaria and 14.5% of falciparum malaria which is similar to the study done by Sonawaneet VB.6 Whereas, in the study done by Verma et al, jaundice was most commonly seen in vivax malaria when compared to the falciparum malaria.7 There is a scarcity of published literature on malarial hepatopathy in children. In acute malaria, hepatic dysfunction is reversible and patients respond favorably to antimalarial therapy with no residual effects. In the present study Thrombocytopenia is more common in falciparum malaria (14.4%) compared to vivax malaria (6.4%) which is similar to the study done by Sonawane VB and Goyal JP et al.6,8 In study done by Verma the incidence of thrombocytopenia is more common in vivax malaria (13.5%) compared to the falciparum malaria (13.5%). In the present study metabolic acidosis is more common in falciparum malaria (2.9%) when compared to the vivax malaria similar observation was noted verma. In the study done by Sonawane VB metabolic acidosis is more common in vivax malaria when compared to the falciparum malaria this variation in the result from the present study could be due vivax malaria is more common contributing to 67% of the cases.6
Hypoglycemia was more common in falciparum malaria (1.4%) when compared to the vivax malaria similar observation was noted in the study done by Verma et al.4 Renal failure is more common in falciparum malaria (2.9%) when compared to vivax malaria similar observation was noted in study done by Goyal JP, Sonawane VB and Singh et al.8,6,9 Whereas study done by verma renal failure is more common in vivax malaria when compared to the falciparum malaria the difference could be due epidemiological variations. ARDS is more common in vivax malaria (2.1%) when compared to the falciparum malaria similar observation was noted in the study done by Goyal and Singh R et al.8,9
In the present study significant bleeding was seen in 2 cases (2.9%) of falciparum malaria which is in contrast to the study done by verma in which bleeding is more common in vivax malaria (13.3%). This difference could be due more severity and incidence of the falciparum malaria in the Telangana state when compared to the northern india in which vivax malaria is more common.12 In the present study shock was seen in falciparum malaria when compared to the vivax malaria similar observation was noted in the study done by tarakeswara rao et al and verma.4,10 Out of 100 cases, 54% has shown normal reticulocyte count, 25% has shown high reticulocyte count and 21% has shown low reticulocyte count. 30.4% of the cases of falciparum malaria showed increased reticulocyte count, whereas, 29% of the cases of vivax malaria has low reticulocyte count which is similar to the observation done by Agrawal D et al.11
CONCLUSION
A total 100 cases of malaria diagnosed by rapid diagnostic test and/or peripheral smear were studied. 69% of the cases were falciparum malaria and 31% of the cases were vivax malaria. Males were more commonly affected than females. Vivax malaria was most common between 5-10 years of age and falciparum malaria was more common in 0-5 years of age. Uncomplicated malaria was seen in 73% of the cases and complicated malaria was seen in 27% of the cases. Incidence of complicated malaria was more common in case of falciparum malaria. Fever, pallor, hepatomegaly and splenomegaly were significant for clinical diagnosis of malaria. Severe anaemia was the most common presentation of complicated malaria followed by jaundice. Cerebral malaria was more common in case of falciparum malaria. Metabolic acidosis and renal failure were more common in falciparum malaria. Hypoglycaemia, significant bleeding and shock were more common in falciparum malaria. ARDS was most common in vivax malaria. In conclusion severe form of malaria is also seen in vivax malaria and should not be neglected.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
- 1. World health organisation, Regional officeof South East Region Health topics:Malaria: World Malaria report 2014. Available at http://www.searo.who.int/entity/malaria/en/. Accessed on 12 November 2014.
- 2. Kochar DK, Sirohi P, Kochar SK. Malaria in India. Ed Singal SK. Medicine update (proceedings of scientific session-APICON. 2007;17:639-648.
- 3. Kochar DK, Singh P, Agarwal P, Kochar SK, Pokharna R, Sareen PK. Malarial hepatitis. J Assoc Physicians India. 2003 Nov;51:1069-72.
- 4. Verma P, Shukla US, Kalraiya A. Retrospective study on clinical profile of severe malaria in children admitted in a tertiary care centre of central India. People’s J Sci Res. 2014;7:22-6.
- 5. Rao PT, Krishna P. Clinical Profile of admitted children with malarial fever: a retrospective study. Int J Pediatr Res. 2016;3
- 6. Sonawane VB, Kotrashetti V, Malhotra R. Comparison of Clinical Profile and Severity of P. falciparum and P. vivax Malaria in a Tertiary Care Hospital of Navi Mumbai, India: A Descriptive Study. JMSCR. 2017;5(1).
- 7. Malaria situation. NVBDCP. Available at http://nvbdcp.gov.in/Doc/malaria-situation.pdf.
- 8. Goyal JP, Makwana AM. Comparison of clinical profile between P. vivax and P. falciparum malaria in children: a tertiary care centre perspective from India. Malaria research and treatment. 2014;2014.
- 9. Singh R, Kumar S, Rana SK, Thakur B, Singh SP. A comparative study of clinical profiles of vivax and falciparum malaria in children at a tertiary care centre in Uttarakhand. JCDR. 2013;7(10):2234.
- 10. Rao PT, Prudhvi K Clinical Profile of admitted children with malarial fever: a retrospective study. Pediatric Review: Int J Pediatri Res. 016;3(9):678-82.
- 11. Agrawal D Teach SJ. Evaluation and Management of a Child with suspected malaria. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2006 Feb; 22(2):127-33.