Original Research Article
Renal diseases in children at the university of Gondar hospital, Ethiopia: pattern and outcome
Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Gondar, Gondar, Ethiopia
Received: 27 March 2024
Revised: 02 May 2024
Accepted: 07 May 2024
*Correspondence:
Dr. Mehretie K. Alemu,
E-mail: mehretiek@gmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: In developing countries, renal diseases in children are becoming common causes of morbidity and mortality. In Ethiopia, there are no adequate data about patterns and outcome of these disorders. We conducted this study to provide evidences on patterns and outcome of renal diseases in children admitted to a tertiary hospital in Gondar, Ethiopia.
Methods: A retrospective record review of all pediatric patients admitted with renal diseases over a period of two-years (January 2022-December 2023) to the university of Gondar hospital (UoGH), was conducted.
Results: A total of 456, comprising 231 (50.7%) females and 225 (49.3%) males, patients were studied. Majority (37.7%) of patients were below 5 years of age. Renal diseases accounted for 3.6% of all admissions during the 2-years period. Common renal problems were urinary tract infection (UTI) (29%), acute glomerulonephritis (AGN) (24.1%), nephrotic syndrome (18.6%), acute kidney injury (AKI) (14.3%), nephroblastoma (9%) and chronic kidney diseases (CKD) (2.4%). Finally; 71.9% were discharged improved and 10.5% died. The highest case fatality rates were in patients with rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis (36.7%) followed by CKD (36.4%), and AKI (21.5%).
Conclusions: This study revealed high prevalence and mortality rate of renal diseases in children. The major causes of death were AGN/RPGN, CKD and AKI. All the above evidences clearly disclosed that establishment of a pediatric nephrology unit and get a trained pediatric nephrologist in our university hospital is critical.
Keywords: Pattern, Outcome, Renal diseases, Children, University of Gondar
INTRODUCTION
Studies from different countries worldwide reported variable patterns and outcome of renal diseases in children.1-3 These variations may be due to differences in genetics, environment or population awareness about the disease. Lack of advanced diagnostic and treatment facilities in our hospital often leads to inaccurate diagnosis and suboptimal treatment. Delayed diagnosis and treatments lead to the progression of renal disorders to the end stage renal injury which results in high morbidity and mortality in children.4,5 Data about pediatric renal diseases in Ethiopia are generally scanty and there is no evidence on patterns and outcome of childhood renal diseases in our hospital. With the final target of establishing pediatric renal services in our hospital; we did a retrospectively report on the patterns and outcome of renal diseases among hospitalized children in our hospital over a 2-years period.
METHODS
Study design and data collection
A retrospective analysis on records of all children (aged 1 month to 18 years) diagnosed with renal disorders admitted to pediatrics emergency and wards of UoGH over 2 years (January 2022 to December 2023). Important information for the study was extracted from the patients’ medical records. Neonates aged <1 month who are being admitted in a separate unit, patients with unknown outcome were excluded. Children readmitted for the same renal disorder were only counted once at the first presentation.
A study checklist with structured questionnaire was used to extract information from the medical records that included demographic characteristics, types of renal diseases, presenting symptoms and signs and outcomes of renal diseases in children aged 1 month-18 years. Each renal disease was diagnosed based on clinical, laboratory and sonographic evaluations. Outcomes included discharged improved, discharge against medical advice (DAMA), disappearance, referral to other hospital or death.
Study area
The UoGH is a tertiary care teaching hospital with different specialties. Department of pediatrics and child health has its own building with a total of 200 beds for children including neonatal ICU. The Hospital serves as a referral center nearly for 10million population within the Amhara and nearby regions. Admitted children were managed by pediatric residents and general pediatricians sometimes in consultation with adult nephrologist since there is no pediatric nephrologist and unit in the Hospital but there is a plan of establishing the unit for which this study will be used as a baseline report.
Sampling and sample size calculation
The sample size was calculated using single population proportion formula by considering the following assumptions; 95% confidence interval, 4% margin of error and 50% proportion of renal diseases.
N = Z2×P(1-p)/e2
N = (1.96)2×0.5 (1-0.5)/(0.04)2
N = 563
Because the calculated sample size couldn’t be achieved, we included all the 456 participants in the study.
Ethical considerations
Ethical clearance was obtained from institutional review board of the university of Gondar. The collected data were used only for the purpose of the proposed study and data were handled carefully and stored with password in the responsible person with no access by other individuals. Name of the participants were omitted from the questionnaire and only medical record number used to ensure confidentiality.
Statistical analysis
Data entry and analysis were performed using a software program statistical package for social science (SPSS) version 26. Descriptive statistics was applied for frequencies, mean, and percentages. The age of patients was summarized as means and standard deviations. Other clinical features (demographic characteristics, the type of renal diseases, and the presenting signs and symptoms) were presented as counts and percentages. The prevalence of renal diseases was calculated based on the renal diseases counts per all the pediatrics diagnoses in the admitted patients over 2-years period.
RESULTS
A total of 456 medical records with the diagnosis of renal diseases were revised in the study. Majority (56.6%) of children were from Gondar town. Fifty one percent (231/456) were females with a female-to-male ratio of 1.04:1. Mean age of children at the time of diagnosis was 6.6±4.3 years (range 1 month-17 years). Nearly 49% of the patients were below 5 years of age, 30.7% aged 5 -10 years, and 20.4% were above 10 years of age (Table 1).
The prevalence of renal disease among all admissions during the 2-years period was 3.6%. The most common presenting feature of renal diseases was edema, followed by reddish discoloration of urine and nonspecific symptoms (Table 2).
A total of 510 diagnoses of renal diseases were detected out of 456 studied children. UTI was the commonest renal diagnosis in the study group, accounting for 29% (132/460 cases), followed by AGN, nephrotic syndrome (NS), and AKI, contributing for 24.1% (110/456), 18.6% (85/456) and 14.3% (65/456) cases of renal diseases, respectively (Table 3).
In patients with NS; the majority (92.4%) of cases were diagnosed as steroid-sensitive, 3.2% as steroid-dependent, and the remaining 4.4% as steroid-resistant cases. Sixty-two out of 110 cases with AGN (56.4%) had clinical and biochemical features of acute post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis (PSGN) including hematuria, edema, hypertension, and ASO positivity. The majority (65.5%) of AKI were due to pre-renal causes resulted from severe fluid losses of acute gastro-enteritis. Sepsis and AGN accounted for 18.5% and 9% of AKI, respectively and remaining 7% due to miscellaneous causes. All of renal tumors were nephroblastoma.
At the end of the study; 71.9% of cases were discharged improved, 10.5% died in the hospital, 9.2% left against medical advice, 6.0% disappeared from the hospital, and 2.4% were referred to other hospitals (Table 4).
AGN, AKI, and RPGN were major causes of death, accounting for 37.5%, 29.2% and 22.9% of deaths, respectively. The case fatality rate was higher in patients with RPGN (36.7%), CKD (36.4%), and AKI (21.5%).
NS=nephrotic syndrome, AGN=acute glomerulonephritis, AKI=acute kidney injury, UTI=urinary tract infections, PUV=posterior urethral valve; CKD=chronic kidney disease; CGN=chronic glomerulonephritis; PCKD=polycystic kidney disease; RPGN=rapid progressive glomerulonephritis.
DISCUSSION
This study describes the patterns and outcome of childhood renal diseases at the UoGH for the first time where there is no pediatric nephrology unit. Dialysis was done only for few children with renal diseases in collaboration with the adult nephrology unit. This retrospective analysis was done with the objective of establishing a pediatric nephrology service in the hospital.
The patterns and outcome of renal diseases in Ethiopian children as a whole is very difficult to determine precisely due to lack of a national data registry. In this study; the prevalence of renal diseases among admitted children was 3.6%. This finding is almost similar to other studies from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia (3.3%), north-western Nigeria (3.2%), and India (2.8%).1,3,6 However; other studies from Tanzania, Nepal, and north-western Nigeria reported higher prevalence rates (16.2%, 6.9%, and 8.9%, respectively).7-9 This variation could be due to the availability of pediatric nephrology services in these set ups so that more referral cases of renal diseases will be seen and also diagnostic facilities and expertise might be another reason for the variation. Other studies from Egypt and north-western Nigeria reported a lower prevalence of 1.15% and 1.2%, respectively.3,4 These reports, which are lower than our results, could be related to the sites of the study area which were done in rural areas where renal admissions could be lower due to early referral to the higher centers.
The most common renal disease requiring hospital admissions in this study was UTI (29%). This finding is similar with published reports from north-western Nigeria (34%), Abuja, Nigeria (30.7%), and Sudan (30%), respectively.3,5,10 However, other studies from African and Asian countries reported NS as the commonest reason for admissions.2,11 this variation could be related to early presentation, prevalence rates of other underlying renal morbidities, and diagnostic challenges. AGN was the second-commonest (24.1%) cause of renal admissions in our study which is comparable with reports from Egypt, North-East India, and Aminu Kano, Nigeria.4,12,13 Our study showed that NS was the third most common (18.6%) cause of admissions. Studies from Cape Town, South Africa, and Dhaka city, Bangladesh showed that NS is the most common renal disease in children.11,14 this variation could be due to a higher rate of infections contributing to Streptococcal infection with PsAGN and UTI in our setting.
AKI was diagnosed in 14.3% of patients in our study. This finding is comparable to other studies from Africa.2,9,11,15 However; studies from Egypt, Nigeria, and Nepal reported a higher prevalence of 29.7%, 30.7%, and 17.9%, respectively.4,5,16 these higher reports could be due to the presence of dialysis and other advanced treatments in the center so that a higher number of referrals are expected. The majority (65.5%) of AKI were due to pre-renal causes resulted from severe fluid losses of acute gastro-enteritis. Sepsis and AGN contributed for 18.5% and 9% cases of AKI, respectively, and the remaining 7% were due to unidentified causes.
At presentation to the Hospital; CKD was reported only in 2.4% of children with renal diseases, which is similar to a report from Nepal (2.2%) but higher figures were reported from other areas: South Africa (6.4%) and Pakistan (29%).8,11,17
This difference is likely due to the lack of proper diagnostic modalities and experts in our set up and early referral to other hospitals before admission.
The only renal tumor reported from this study was Nephroblastoma which was diagnosed in 41 (9%) children, which is in parallel with study from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia (6.3%) but a lower rate (3.7%) was reported from Abuja, Nigeria.1,5 The higher report of this study is explained by the fact that children with Nephroblastoma are being admitted and treated in the pediatric ward by a pediatric oncologist.
In this study; congenital kidney and urinary tract anomalies were reported in very few children (1.5%) in which PUV was reported in 5 and PCKD in 2 cases. However, other researches from Egypt and India reported 14.1% and 24.7% cases of CAKU, respectively.4,6 This significantly low report may be due to lack of prenatal screening services, awareness of caretakers, and advanced diagnostic modalities in our setup.
At the end of the study; 71.9% of cases were discharged improved, 15.2%, 9.2% left against medical advice, 6% disappeared from the hospital, 10.5% were died in the hospital and 2.4% were referred to other hospitals. The mortality rate of 10.5% is higher than reports from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia (2.9%), south-east Nigeria (4.8%), north-western Nigeria (2.9%) and Sri Lanka (0.7%) but higher mortality rate (14.4%) was reported from South-Western Nigeria.1-3,18,19 These variations in mortality rate could be related to the level of the facility since there is no advanced care in our set up, it is expected to have higher mortality. In our report, majority 29/48 (60.4%) of deaths were due to RPGN, CKD and AKI with fatality rate of 36.7%, 36.4% and 21.5%, respectively. Lack of dialysis facilities and pediatric nephrology service as a whole were major contributors of mortality in our study which could be also the explanation for the higher mortality rate. Most of these renal morbidities and mortalities can be prevented with early diagnosis and management. This can be achieved by establishment of pediatric renal unit and avail trained pediatric nephrologists in the university hospital.
Limitations
This study is a retrospective study, and data accuracy may be questioned, and the loss of medical records undermines the magnitude of renal diseases in the setup.
CONCLUSION
This study presented an insight about the patterns and outcome of childhood renal diseases at the UoGH. The three major renal problems were UTI, AGN, and NS. The prevalence and mortality rate were high in this study. The major causes of death were AGN/RPGN, CKD, and AKI. All the above evidences clearly indicate establishment of a pediatric nephrology unit and getting a trained pediatric nephrologist in our university hospital is critical.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Authors would like to thank all the staffs in the medical records departments in our hospital for their support and cooperation during data collection.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
- 1. Mola K, ShimelisD. Pattern and outcome of renal diseases in hospitalized children in Tikur Anbessa specialized teaching hospital, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Ethiopian Med J. 2016;54(3):117-23.
- 2. Okoronkwo CN, Chiappjumbo UA, Onyire NB, Ekpemo CS, Ijeoma NS. Pattern of Childhood Renal Diseases in Aba, South East Nigeria. Am J Pediatr. 2020;6(3):278.
- 3. Abdullahi U. Paediatric renal diseases in a rural tertiary hospital in north-western Nigeria: pattern and outcome. J Egypt Society Nephrol Transplantation. 2017;17(1):38.
- 4. Ahmad A, Badawy A, Khalifa A. Pattern of Renal Diseases among Children Admitted to Assiut University Children Hospital. GEGET. 2019;14(1):57-62.
- 5. Anigilaje E, Adesina T. The pattern and outcomes of childhood renal diseases at the University of Abuja Teaching Hospital, Abuja, Nigeria: A 4-year retrospective review. Nigerian Postgraduate Med J. 2019;26(1):53.
- 6. Thakkar KA, Poyekar SS. Pattern of pediatric renal diseases in a rural tertiary care hospital. Int J Contemporary Pediatr. 2020;7(11):2152.
- 7. Chami N, Kabyemera R, Masoza T, Ambrose E, Kimaro F, Kayange N, et al. Prevalence and factors associated with renal dysfunction in children admitted to two hospitals in North Western Tanzania. BMC Nephrol. 2019;20(1):79.
- 8. Malla T, Malla K, Thapalial A, Sharma M. An overview of renal diseases in children in Pokhara. J Nepal Paediatr Society. 2017;27(2):75-8.
- 9. Garba BI, Muhammad AS, Obasi AB, Adeniji AO. Presentation and pattern of childhood renal diseases in Gusau, North-Western Nigeria. S Afr J Child Heal. 2017;11(2):96.
- 10. EL-Tigani MAA, Rahman AH, Karrar ZA. Pattern and outcome of renal diseases in hospitalized children in Khartoum State, Sudan. Sudan J Paediatr. 2012;12(2)52-9.
- 11. Okpechi I, Swanepoel C, Duffield M, Mahala B, Wearne N, Alagbe S, et al. Patterns of renal disease in Cape Town, South Africa: a 10-year review of a single-center renal biopsy database. Nephrol Dialysis Transplantation. 2010;26(6):1853-61.
- 12. Sonowal R. Profile of renal diseases in North-East Indian children. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transplantation. 2019;30(5):1151.
- 13. Obiagwu P, Lugga A, Abubakar A. Pattern of renal diseases in children attending the pediatric nephrology clinic of Aminu Kano Teaching Hospital, Kano Niger J Clin Pract. 2019;22(7):920.
- 14. Qader A, Muinuddin G, Rahman H. Renal Diseases in Children Attending Pediatric Nephrology Centers in Dhaka City. J Ped Nephrol. 2016;4(3):86-91.
- 15. Kayange NM, Smart LR, Tallman JE, Chu EY, Fitzgerald DW, Pain KJ, et al. Kidney disease among children in sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic review. Pediatr Res. 2014;77(2):272-81.
- 16. Shah G, Yadav S, Mishra O, Baral N. Pattern of renal diseases in children: A developing country experience. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transplantation. 2016;27(2):371.
- 17. Moorani KN, Asim A, Shahid A. Patterns of Kidney Diseases in Children. Pak Pediatr. 2013;37(1):26-33.
- 18. Sathiadas MG, Anantharajah A, Vadivel N. Clinical profile of children with renal disease admitted to a tertiary care center in Sri Lanka. Sri Lanka J Child Health. 2021;50(1):87.
- 19. Ladapo T, Esezobor C, Lesi F. Pediatric kidney diseases in an African country: Prevalence, spectrum and outcome. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transplantation. 2014;25(5):1110.