Original Research Article
Playing it down - effectiveness of clay therapy, origami and building blocks in the management of dental anxiety among children aged 6-10 years
Department of Pediatric and Preventive Dentistry, M. R. Ambedkar Dental College and Hospital, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India
Received: 02 May 2023
Revised: 05 June 2023
Accepted: 07 June 2023
*Correspondence:
Dr. Smrithi Srinivasan,
E-mail: drsmrithi1@gmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: Children experience dental anxiety during their first dental visit, which affects the quality of dental treatment and gives rise to behaviour management problems. Clay, origami and building blocks have been effective in alleviating hospitalization anxiety in pediatric patients. These successful techniques in hospitalized pediatric patients have seldom been used in the dental set up. Therefore, the aim of this study is to assess and compare the efficacy of clay therapy, origami and building blocks in the management of dental anxiety in children aged 6-10 years.
Methods: Sixty children aged 6-10 years, with no previous dentist exposure, with Frankl’s behaviour rating 2 or 3 having dental caries with international caries detection and assessment system (ICDAS) score 3 requiring restorations without local anesthesia were selected and divided into four groups. Group 1 – clay therapy; group 2 - building blocks; group 3 – origami; and group 4 – tell show do. Pulse rate, facial image scale (FIS) and face, leg, activity, cry, consolability (FLACC) behaviour scales were used to quantify anxious behaviour. Operator compliance and parent acceptance was rated on the Likert scale.
Results: The results showed lower mean pulse rates, lower FIS and FLACC scores, and better operator compliance and parental acceptance in clay therapy, origami and building blocks groups than in the conventional tell-show-do group. The most significant reduction in all the parameters was seen in the clay therapy group.
Conclusions: Clay therapy, origami and building blocks can be used as an effective means to reduce dental anxiety in children.
Keywords: Dental anxiety, Clay, Play dough, Origami, Building blocks, Behaviour management, Tell show do
INTRODUCTION
Dental anxiety is commonly experienced among children especially during their first dental visit. This can be attributed to the uncertainty and scepticism regarding what awaits them in the dental setting.1,2 This can influence their behaviour and can also cause negligence of treatment, impacting their health negatively.1
The first dental experience is important in shaping the child’s attitude towards dental treatment.1 Cooperation of the child during dental treatment is integral for successful treatment. The child finds the sight, sound and sensation of the airotor to be the stimuli that elicits fear in the dental operatory.3 The means to overcome dental anxiety has been long pursued.
The tell-show-do (TSD) technique is one of the most commonly used nonpharmacologic methods in pediatric dentistry. According to this technique, before any procedure is done, the child is to be given a verbal explanation (tell), a demonstration (show) and the procedure is performed without deviating from the explanation and demonstration (do).4 However, the child might still be threatened by the new stimuli leading to anxiety.
Clay has been used as a toy for children and as a tool of play therapy. Clay provides children with a method of expression. Clay therapy is a simple technique which guides the attention of the child away from stress-inducing stimuli and towards a pleasant and exciting process.5
Origami is the art of paper folding that originated from Japan and has been commonly practiced worldwide. It derived its name from the Japanese word ‘oru’ as in ‘to fold’, and ‘kami’ as in ‘paper’.6 There are models in origami such as, geometrical shapes, toys and animals which are simple and easy for the children to follow.7
Building blocks helps children engage in significant mathematical thinking and reasoning.8 It is non- directive play therapy that considers play as a healing process. It can reduce the traumatic experience of the child in the hospital and aids in the recovery phase.9
These traditional techniques are familiar, easy to perform, require no special equipment and are cost effective.
These successful techniques in hospitalized pediatric patients have seldom been used in the dental set up. Therefore, the present study was conducted to assess and compare the efficacy of clay therapy, origami and building blocks in reducing dental anxiety among children aged 6-10 years.
METHODS
This was a randomized interventional clinical study performed after obtaining approval from institutional review board and ethics committee, M. R. Ambedkar Dental College and Hospital, Bengaluru and is registered with clinical trials registry of India (CTRI/2023/04/051882).
The study was conducted in April 2023 for a duration of one month. Sixty children aged between 6 years and 10 years, who visited the dental clinic for the first time with no previous dental experience, were selected after a written informed consent from the patient’s parents/ guardians and an assent from the children was obtained.
Inclusion criteria
Children aged 6-10 years with no previous dentist exposure, children with Frankl’s behaviour rating 2 or 3, and dental caries with a localized enamel breakdown without clinical signs of dentinal involvement, international caries detection and assessment system (ICDAS) score 3 requiring restorations without local anesthesia were included.10-12
Exclusion criteria
Children with a previous history of dental treatment, children whose parents gave a history of systemic illnesses, physical or intellectual disabilities, and children whose parents do not give consent were excluded.1,11
Using simple random sampling technique, the selected children were equally distributed into four groups of 15 each, namely group 1 – clay therapy; group 2 – origami; group 3 – building blocks; group 4 – control group - tell show do.
In the clay group, the children were encouraged to form some shapes of their choice with play dough, five minutes prior to the procedure. The children were helped in forming the shapes based on their needs and in doing so, the dentist will try to communicate with the children.5
In the origami group, the children were given an option to make the origami based on his/her preference out of colour paper of the child’s choice. The first step in making the toy was initiated by the operator and the child was asked to repeat the same. If the child was not able to complete the toy, he/she was helped by the operator to redo the origami.13
In the building blocks group, the children were given building blocks and asked to build a tower.8
In the tell show do (TSD) group, in the “tell” phase the whole procedure was explained to the children. In the “show” phase, the children were made familiar with the instruments and the procedure was demonstrated. In the “do” phase, the operator began dental treatment exactly as per the explanation and demonstration given to the children.4
Standard sterilization protocols were followed to disinfect the materials before and after each child uses it.
Children in each group were treated in a single appointment after being subjected to one of the four interventions. The tools used in the study are shown in Figures 1-3.
Four different parameters were measured: pulse rate before, after intervention and after treatment; face, leg, activity, cry, consolability (FLACC) scale during the treatment procedure; facial image scale (FIS) after treatment; and patient compliance and acceptance through a 5-point Likert scale by both the dentist and the parent.
A pulse oximeter was used to measure the pulse rate. The FLACC behavioural pain assessment scale was used by the operator to grade the child’s behaviour during treatment. The FIS was used and the patient was asked to select the image from the FIS that he/she can closely associate with at that moment. Likert scale is a 5-point scale, where the operator and the parent rated the Likert scale based on the ease of handling of the patient.
The data collected was tabulated and subjected to the following statistical analyses performed using statistical package for the social sciences (SPSS) statistical software package version 22.0. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) test followed by Tukey’s post hoc analysis was used to compare the mean pulse rate between 4 groups at different time intervals.
Kruskal Wallis test followed by Dunn’s post hoc test was used to compare the mean facial image rating scale scores between 4 groups at different time intervals. Chi square test was used to compare the FLACC scale scores between 4 groups at different time intervals. The level of significance (p value) was set at p<0.05.
RESULTS
The sample comprised of 60 children (32 males; 28 females) with 53.3% males and 46.7% females in group 1 and 2, 46.7% males and 53.3% females in group 3 and 60% males and 40% females in group 4.
Among the children between 6 and 10 years, group 1 (mean age±SD: 7.33±1.23) received clay therapy, group 2 (mean age±SD: 8.13±1.36) received origami, group 3 (mean age±SD: 7.67±1.40) received building blocks (mean age±SD: 7.67±1.23) and group 4 (mean age±SD: 7.67±1.23) received tell show do technique (Table 1).
Pre-intervention anxiety levels as indicated by the pulse rate showed no statistical significance during the pre - intervention period in any group (Table 2).
There was a significant reduction in pulse rate after the intervention in all the four groups which was statistically significant (p<0.001). A statistically significant difference was obtained between group 1 and 2 (p=0.008), group 1 and groups 3 and 4 (p<0.001), group 2 and 3 (p=0.01), group 2 and 4 (p<0.001) and groups 3 and 4 (p=0.003) after the intervention (Figure 4).
There was a significant reduction in mean pulse rate, after treatment in all the groups. There was a significant reduction in mean pulse rate, after treatment, for group 1, group 2 and group 3 indicating low anxiety levels in these groups when compared to group 4. A statistically significant difference was obtained between group 1 and groups 2, 3, 4 (p<0.001), group 2 and group 3 (p=0.01), group 2 and group 4 (p<0.001), group 3 and group 4 (p=0.001) after the treatment (Figure 4).
The FLACC scores showed that 80% of the patients were relaxed in clay therapy group, followed by 66.7% of the patients in origami group, 53.3% of the patients in building blocks group and 73.3% of the patients in the tell show do group showed mild discomfort that was statistically significant (p<0.001) (Figure 5). Group 1 showed a mean FIS score of 1 which was the least, followed by group 2, 3 and 4.
A statistically significant difference between the mean FIS scores was obtained between group 1 and 2 (p=0.003), group 1 with groups 3 and 4 (p<0.001). A statistically significant difference was also seen between group 2 and 3 (p=0.04) and groups 2 and 4 (p<0.001) and group 3 and 4 (p<0.001) (Table 3).
It was appreciably easier to handle the patient during treatment and carry out the dental procedure in the clay therapy, origami and building blocks groups when compared to tell-show-do group with p<0.001, which was statistically significant (Table 3). The parents rated clay to be the most acceptable intervention with 86.7% rating it as very good, 53.3% rated origami as very good, 40% rated building blocks as very good and 86.7% rated tell show do as a good technique which is statistically significant (p<0.001) (Table 3).
The observers rated clay to be the most acceptable intervention with 86.7% rating it as very good, 60% rated origami as very good, 46.7% rated building blocks as very good and 20% rated tell show do as very good which is statistically significant (p<0.001) (Table 3).
DISCUSSION
Children aged 6-10 years have been chosen for this study as the prevalence of dental anxiety among 5 to 10-year-old children in an Indian population has been found to be 6.3% with a gradual decrease with age.14
Clay, origami and building blocks have been used in reducing anxiety in hospitalized children. These materials which are familiar to the child at school and at home can bring down anxiety rather than introducing a new stimulus.
Clay used as a therapeutic tool has been effective for children in improving their problem-solving skills, in self-esteem enhancement, decision-making processes, and control of impulses, creating a calm and safe atmosphere.5,15,16
Origami is a promising, cost effective, nonpharmacological technique to reduce hospitalized anxiety and can be used to enhance intellectual and cognitive process while being admitted in the hospital.7,13,17
Building blocks helps children engage in significant mathematical thinking and reasoning. It is said to be non-directive play therapy and considers play a healing process. It can reduce the traumatic effects of experience in hospital and aids in recovery phase. They have been used in pediatric patients hospitalized for surgery to reduce their anxiety.8,9
Tell show do is the most commonly used technique that helps the child to get familiarized with the dental setting and thereby, reducing the anxiety. There was a reduction in the anxiety level in the tell show do group and the findings were consistent with the results of Rajeshwari et al, Azher et al, and Asokan et al.8,11,18
Pulse rate is the simplest biological parameter to measure and an increase in heart rate is the most common physiological indicator for anxiety.12 It has been used as a physiological parameter to measure anxiety in various studies.1,2,18 Therefore, pulse rate was used to predict the effectiveness of these interventions in reducing dental anxiety in the present study.
The mean difference in pulse rate after the intervention was highest between group 1 and 4 (p<0.001), followed by group 1 and 3 (p<0.001) and group 1 and 2 (p=0.008).
The pulse rate reduced after the intervention and after the treatment in all the four groups out of which the most significant reduction was about 24% in clay therapy (p<0.001).
The mean difference in pulse rate after intervention between groups 1 and 4 is the highest (p<0.001) followed by groups 1 and 3 (p<0.001), groups 1 and 2 (p=0.008). The mean difference in pulse rate after treatment between groups 1 and 4 is the highest (p<0.001), followed by groups 1 and 3 and 1 and 2 (p<0.001).
FIS was used to quantify and evaluate anxiety.20 According to a study by Buchanan and Niven, FIS is a valid means of assessing child dental anxiety status apart from being valid and cost effective.19,21,22
In the present study, the mean FIS was lower in the clay therapy group compared to the other groups indicating low anxiety levels compared to the other groups.
The mean difference in FIS was the most between groups 1 and 4, followed by groups 1 and 3 and groups 1 and 2.
FLACC scale was used to assess disruptive behaviour as it provided excellent validity and reliability.23,24
The FLACC scale showed 80% of the children were “relaxed” during the treatment after receiving clay therapy.
In this study, it was found that 86.7% of both the operators and the parents rated clay therapy as a very good intervention.
Clay showed 24% reduction in pulse rate post intervention and post treatment, and FLACC score showed more than half of the patients being relaxed along with the mean FIS being 1.
Clay is a form of unstructured play and the end model need not be perfect. Clay enhances the creativity of the child and can lead to unlimited possibilities. It is a kinesthetic experience and each child feels accomplished after the hands-on experience. This might explain why clay reduced anxiety in children.
The results of this study were consistent with previous studies where clay was compared with bubble making, paint therapy and narrative therapy, and clay therapy resulted in decreased anxiety levels.7,15,16
Origami showed 10% reduction in pulse rate post intervention and post treatment, and FLACC score showed more than half of the patients being “relaxed” along with the mean FIS being 1.47.
Origami involves following a set of instructions to reach an end goal. Children who are perfectionists and prefer following rules to reach a goal may prefer this. This could be attributed to the reduction in anxiety levels in the origami group. The results of this study were consistent with previous studies where origami was compared with control groups, puzzles and origami resulted in decreased anxiety levels.7,13,17
Building blocks showed 7.5% reduction in pulse rate post intervention and post treatment, and FLACC score showed half of the patients being relaxed along with the mean FIS being 2.
Children with better spatial reasoning and hand eye co-ordination may have performed well in this group. This could be the reason building blocks helped in reducing anxiety. The results of this study were consistent with previous studies where building blocks were compared with audiovisual aids and conventional physiotherapy where origami resulted in decreased anxiety levels.8,9
86.7% of the parents rated clay as a very good intervention, followed by 53.3% who rated origami as a very good intervention, 40% who rated building blocks as a very good intervention. 86.7% of the parents rated tell show do as a good intervention.
This may be attributed to the fact that the techniques involve no screen time or gadgets to reduce the child’s anxiety. These techniques are proven to be effective and can be incorporated into clinical practice whenever necessary.
Limitations
The children in our study group were randomly assigned into the different groups. We did not take into consideration or classify the children based on their appeal and ability. Further studies can be conducted based on evaluation of each child.
CONCLUSION
Clay therapy, origami, building blocks and tell show do show a reduction in anxiety. Among the groups, clay therapy showed the most significant reduction in pulse rate (p<0.001) compared to the other three groups. FLACC scores showed 80 % of the patients were “relaxed” in clay therapy. Clay therapy showed a mean FIS of 1 which was significantly lesser than the other three groups. 86% of the parents and the operator rated clay therapy as a great tool to reduce anxiety.
Recommendations
These traditional methods are simple, accessible, easy to perform, cost effective, require no special equipment, involves no screen time and can be done chairside. They have thus been proven to be effective and can be incorporated into clinical practice whenever necessary.
In the future, the appropriate technique can be chosen based on the child’s preference or the parents’ history or a combination of both. They can also be used in case of space restraints. These techniques can be used by a consultant as it is portable and travel friendly.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Authors would like to thank Dr. Santhosh for helping us with statistical analyses. They are grateful to the children and their parents for their participation in the study.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
- 1. Panchal J, Panda A, Trivedi K, Chari D, Shah R, Parmar B. Comparative evaluation of the effectiveness of two innovative methods in the management of anxiety in a dental office: a randomized controlled trial. J Dent Anesth Pain Med. 2022;22(4):295.
- 2. Alsaadoon AM, Sulimany AM, Hamdan HM, Murshid EZ. The use of a dental storybook as a dental anxiety reduction medium among pediatric patients: a randomized controlled clinical trial. Children. 2022;9(3):328.
- 3. Vishwakarma AP, Bondarde PA, Patil SB, Dodamani AS, Vishwakarma PY, Mujawar SA. Effectiveness of two different behavioral modification techniques among 5–7-year-old children: A randomized controlled trial. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2017;35:143-9.
- 4. American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. Behavior guidance for the pediatric dental patient. The Reference Manual of Pediatric Dentistry. Chicago, Ill. American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. 2022;321-39.
- 5. Maghsoudi S, Sajjadi Z, Behnam Vashani H, Asghari Nekah SM, Manzari ZS. Comparison of the effects of play dough and bubble making distraction techniques on venepuncture pain intensity in children. Evidence Based Care. 2016;5(4):25-32.
- 6. Yodmon C. Origami in Medical field: a review article. Int J Curr Res. 2020;12(10):14566-8.
- 7. Thakur M, Kaur N, Pooni PA. Effectiveness of Origami on Hospitalized Anxiety among Children Admitted in Paediatric Units of a Selected Tertiary Care Hospital Ludhiana, Punjab. J Pediatr Nurs. 2021;7(2):1-9.
- 8. Rajeswari SR, Chandrasekhar R, Vinay C, Uloopi KS, RojaRamya KS, Ramesh MV. Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Play Therapy and Audiovisual Distraction for Management of Preoperative Anxiety in Children. Int J Clin Pediatr Dent. 2019;12(5):419-22.
- 9. Deshpande R, Shah MR. Effectiveness of Play Therapy on Pain and Anxiety in Children Post Surgery. Int J Health Sci. 2019;9(4):84-9.
- 10. Rao DG, Havale R, Nagaraj M, Karobari NM, Latha AM, Tharay N, et al. Assessment of Efficacy of Virtual Reality Distraction in Reducing Pain Perception and Anxiety in Children Aged 6–10 Years: A Behavioral Interventional Study. Int J Clin Pediatr Dent. 2019;12(6):510-3.
- 11. Azher U, Srinath SK, Nayak M. Effectiveness of Bubble Breath Play Therapy in the Dental Management of Anxious Children: A Pilot Study. J Contemp Dent Pract. 2020;21(1):17-21.
- 12. Bafna Y, Chokshi MJ, Patel D. Comparison of Digital Games as a Behaviour Modification Among Anxious Children Aged 4-8 Years. J Res Adv Dent. 2021;11(3):237-41.
- 13. Mathew CS. Effectiveness of origami on hospitalized anxiety among children. Int J Adv Sci Res Dev. 2018;3(8):169-73.
- 14. Chhabra N, Chhabra A, Walia G. Prevalence of dental anxiety and fear among five to ten year old children: A behaviour based cross sectional study. Minerva Stomatol. 2012;61:83-9.
- 15. Zaynaliyan G, Javani A, Abedi M. Comparing the effect of paint and clay therapy on the symptoms of separation anxiety disorders in pre-school children. India J Fundament Appl Life Sci. 2014;4(3):304-14.
- 16. Rahmani P, Moheb N. The effectiveness of clay therapy and narrative therapy on anxiety of pre-school children: a comparative study. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2010;5:23-7.
- 17. Pribadi T, Elsanti D, Yulianto A. Reduction of Anxiety in Children Facing Hospitalization By Play Therapy: Origami and Puzzle in Lampung-Indonesia. Malahayati Int J Nurs Health Sci. 2018;1(1):29-35.
- 18. Asokan S, Geetha Priya PR, Natchiyar SN, Elamathe M. Effectiveness of distraction techniques in the management of anxious children –A randomized controlled pilot trial. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2020;38:407-12.
- 19. Buchanan H, Niven N. Validation of a facial image scale to assess child dental anxiety. Int J Paediatr Dent. 2002;12:47 52.
- 20. Fathima F, Jeevanandan G. Validation of a facial image scale to assess child dental anxiety. Drug Invent Today. 2018;10:2825-8.
- 21. James J, Retnakumari N, Vadakkepurayil K, Thekkeveetil AK, Tom A. Effectiveness of Aromatherapy and Music Distraction in Managing Pediatric Dental Anxiety: A Comparative Study. Int J Clin Pediatr Dent. 2021;14(2):249-53.
- 22. Deshpande AN, Shah YS, Jain A. Effectiveness of Euphemism with and without Self-designed Pictorial Flashcard in the Form of Dental Pictionary as Behavior Modification Technique in 4–6-year-old Children: A Randomized Controlled Study. J South Asian Assoc Pediatr Dent. 2022;5(2):59-63.
- 23. Sharma D, Sheth M, Bhatt R. A New Experience for Child in Pediatric Dental Clinic during Pulp Therapy Procedures with the Google Card board Device. RGUHS J Med Sci. 2021;11(2):106-12.
- 24. Bahrololoomi Z, Sadeghiyeh T, Rezaei M, Maghsoudi N. The Effect of Breathing Exercise Using Bubble Blower on Anxiety and Pain during Inferior Alveolar Nerve Block in Children Aged 7 to 10 Years: A Crossover Randomized Clinical Trial. Pain Res Management. 2022;17.