Original Research Article
Educational needs assessment of faculty members in Ardabil University of Medical Sciences
1Department of surgery, Iran University of Medical Science, Tehran, Iran
2Faculty of Medicine, Ardabil University of Medical Science, Ardabil, Iran
Received: 10 September 2017
Revised: 04 October 2017
Accepted: 05 October 2017
*Correspondence:
Dr. Esmaeil Farzaneh,
E-mail: dr.farzaneh.milad@gmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: Identifying the educational needs is an essential step in planning faculty development programs and plays an important role in promoting the quality of education and can help educational planners to be able to design effective strategies based on available resources and provide effective training. The aim of this study was to determine the educational needs of faculty members in medical school of Ardabil University of Medical Sciences.
Methods: This is a descriptive cross-sectional study that has been done on 88 faculty academic members in two clinical and basic groups Data collected by a questionnaire and collected data were analyzed using statistical methods in SPSS.20.
Results: 53.4% of cases were in group clinical and rests of them were in basic group. 75% of cases were male and rest of them were female. 57% had more than 10 years of work experience. There was a significant difference between two groups in the field of research in the area ethics in research and in the field of information technology in the area of using electronic resources between two groups. Based on the prioritization of the needs within the clinical and basic academic members, the greatest need in both groups was related to the writing of scientific texts in English. Also, the lowest priorities within the clinical and basic members were the familiarity with English journals (26.8%) and the use of electronic resources (27.7%).
Conclusions: Results showed that the level and type of needs among university faculty members fits with the needs of the faculty members in other universities that is required to response the needs of clinical and basic professors, necessary educational and research actions based on the priorities in 6 areas will happen in future.
Keywords: Needs assessment, Educational, Academic members, Ardabil
INTRODUCTION
Training means any kind of activity or pre-programmed change that aims to create learning in individuals and make the necessary changes in the person's behavior in order to meet the need.1
The advancement and development of organizations and institutions need to increase the level of knowledge, insight, skills and behavior of human resources, and the need for planning in organizations and educational institutions is the desirability of using limited resources and facilities and achieving maximum productivity. Due to the fact that in a systematic and realistic planning, reliable, comprehensive and accurate information is needed, so the need assessment process has been considered more than ever.2
Since the scientific and methodological needs assessment has been considered in recent years and the techniques and models of this process are in developing and expanding, so the lack of attention to the needs assessment in the educational curriculum system of Iran severely threatens the results of educational programs. Academic members, as one important section of educational system in country and empowering them in different fields, such as teaching and research, help to achieve the goals of the educational institutions. The main mission of the University of Medical Sciences is to develop human resources for the health promotion of the community. With the increasing number of medical students and establishment of new schools, educational needs and ways to improve the quality of education continuously need to be monitored in order to prevent a drop in the level of graduates of medical sciences in the country. University academic members responsible for educating the new generation who need to provide these services. Therefore, it is necessary for professors to be familiar with teaching, planning and educational assessment methods.3,4
A few studies have been done about identifying the educational needs and clinical teaching skills of faculty members in the country and because of no study has been done in Ardabil University of Medical Science, the aim of this study was to investigate the educational needs assessment of Ardabil University Academic members.
METHODS
This is a descriptive-cross sectional study that has been done on 88 academic members which selected randomly from all clinical and basic groups from Apr 2015 to April 2016. The inclusion criteria is currently the academic member of university. Collected data by a questionnaire included characterized and needs assessment scale in 6 categories (research, general, English language, assessment, education and learning and information technology) which fits with number of academic members in basic and clinical faculties. Collected data analyzed by statistical methods such as table, graph and statistical indexes in SPSS.19.
RESULTS
Of all 88 members, 53.4% were clinical and rest of them were basic. Of all members 75% were male and 46.6% were in age group 40-50. Of them 55.7% were associate professor and 62.5% had PhD and specialty. Of all members, 57% had work experience more than 10 year. Needs assessment was determined on the basis of prioritization within the questions of each area. In the field of research in topic “ethics in research” the difference between two groups was significant (Table 1).
In the field of information technology in topic “using electronic resources” the rate of need in clinical group was significantly more than basic groups (Table 2).
In the field of assessment in topic “Educational progress tests and their analysis” the difference between two groups was significant (Table 3).
In the field of English language there wasn’t any difference between two groups (Table 4).
In the field of education and learning apart from the issues of familiarity with the design of the question, attention to in-person training, the formation of educational tours at universities and the provision of educational packages of each discipline by the ministry, in other respects, the difference between the clinical and the basic group was statistically significant (Table 5).
In the field of general in topics “understanding the duties and responsibilities of a faculty member, the need for training in the field of administrative rules and regulations, and the need for familiarization with educational rules” the difference between two groups wasn’t significant but in other topics it was significant (Table 6).
Prioritizing the needs of the clinical group, writing scientific texts in English with 55.3% is the most and using English and Persian journals with 27.7% is the least priority (Table 7).
Also, within basic group, writing scientific texts in English, take specialized language courses and have the necessary training facilities each with 63.4% is the most and known English journals with 26.8% is the least priority (Table 8).
DISCUSSION
Results showed that most of academic members were middle aged men with a work experience of less than ten years which in clinical group a few more than basic group. Among six needs assessment fields, there was significant difference between two groups in the education and learning field with 19 topics, general with 6 topics, assessment and information technology and research each with one topic. At the highest level of clinical and basic groups needs assessment, writing scientific texts in English, writing paper in English, Spend specialized language courses , familiar with open access journal, use of sabbatical duration, case report and management courses, having facilities for education, using statistical software and digital library, familiar with computer skills, analysis academic achievement tests and strategic programing.
In the lowest needs assessment between the two clinical and basic groups, the design of the lesson plan, oral test, patients’ rights and students, written articles in Persian, the use of Persian and English journals and electronic resources, translation of specialized texts, attention to non-instructive education, test multi-choice, familiar with administrative laws and regulations were the least needed.
In Asadi and et al study, all of academic members declared their needs for English and computer learning which was more than our study results.5
In Toulabi and et al study, English writing technique, speaking English, learning statistics and SPSS, using digital library and search electronic resources are the needs of clinical group and the primary and advanced teaching methods were the educational needs of faculty members of Lorestan University of Medical Sciences, which was somewhat consistent with the present study.6
In Asadi and et al study, design lesson plan and virtual tutorials as an important educational need which in our study attention to virtual tutorials and design lesson plan is in the least need which was in line with Esfahan and Qom study.5,7,8
In Mirzaei and et al study, in the field of education and learning, the most need for new methods of teaching and the least need for Journal Club but in our study in two clinical and basic groups the most need for use of short-term training courses and having the necessary facilities for training and at least was the lesson plan design and attention to virtual tutorials. In the field of assessment in clinical and basic group, the most need for oral test and analysis of academic achievement tests and the least need for case report and multi-choice tests which not in line with Mirzaei study.2
In the field of research, use of statistical software in two groups and writing paper in English in basic group was the most and writing paper in Persian was the least need but in Mirzaei study writing paper in English and ethics in research was the most and least needs, respectively. In the field of information technology, the most need in clinical and basic groups were familiar with English journals, use of digital library and familiar with computer skills and the least need for use of electronic resources and English - Persian journals, respectively. In the field general, the most need for strategic programing in basic group and in clinical group management courses and the least need for professional ethics and education in the field of administrative laws in clinical and basic groups but in Mirzaei study, the most need for student relationship method and the least need for professional ethics. In the field of English language, the most need for writing texts in English in two groups and the least need for spend the English courses and translation of specialized language texts which in line with Mirzaei study.2
CONCLUSION
Determine and prioritize the educational needs of faculty members by educational groups can be an important step in the design and planning of education in line with the needs of the faculty and improve the quality of education. According to the total needs assessment results of academic members in Ardabil University of Medical Science, Most of the discussed topics were the faculty members' educational needs and it is suggested that, in addition to holding training courses and workshops on the needs identified, the necessary steps should be taken to create a dynamic and continuous assessment system at the university in the future.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
- 1. Malekshahi F, Sheikheyan A, Ebrahimzadeh F. Faculty lecturers’ attitudes towards some educational indicators at Lorestan university of medical sciences. Yafte. 2011;12(2):34-43.
- 2. Mirzaei Karzan A, Keikhavani S, Hosseinzade M, Aeivazi AA. Educational Needs Assessment of Faculty Members in Ilam UMS. J Med Edu Dev. 2013;6(11):61-71.
- 3. Barratt MS, Moyer VA. Effect of a teaching skills program on faculty skills and confidence. Ambulatory Pediatrics. 2004;4(1):117-20.
- 4. Farhadian F, Tootoonchi M, Changiz T, Haghani F, Oveis Gharan S. Faculty Members' Skills and Educational Needs Concerning Clinical Teaching Methods in Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. Iranian J Med Edu. 2007;7(1):109-18.
- 5. Asadi A, Taheri M, Salari A. The Survey of Educational Needs to Empower Faculties in GUMS. Research in Medical Education. 2016;8(2):37-48.
- 6. Toulabi T, Sheikhian A, Galehdar N, Anbari K, Mohammadi E, Majidimehr M. Educational needs of faculty members of Lorestan University of Medical Sciences by Delphi Technique. 3 JNE. 2015;4(2):28-37.
- 7. Taheri M, Asadi A, Khoshrang H. Educational Needs Assessment of Faculty Members in GUMS. Res Med Edu. 2007;1(1):21-8.
- 8. Avijgan M, Karamalian H, Ashourioun V, Changiz T. Educational Needs Assessment of Medical School's Clinical Faculty Members in Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. Iranian J Med Edu. 2009;9(2):93-103.