International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392 http://www.ijcmph.com pISSN 2394-6032 | eISSN 2394-6040
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.18203/2394-6040.ijcmph20232026
Original Research Article
Role of community health volunteers in promoting uptake of cervical
cancer screening among women of reproductive age,
Nairobi City, Kenya
Nicholas M. Ojwang*, Margaret N. Keraka, Judy W. Mugo
Department of Population and Reproductive Health, Community Resource Management, School of Health Sciences, Kenyatta University, Nairobi, Kenya
Received: 27 April 2023 Revised: 19 June 2023 Accepted: 21 June 2023 *Correspondence: Dr. Nicholas M. Ojwang, E-mail: nicholasmado@gmail.com Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT Background: Cervical cancer is a significant cause of mortality among women, particularly in developing countries. Africa has highest number of cases, with 85% occurring in developing nations. In Nairobi, low uptake of cervical cancer screening has been realized. Study explores role of CHVs in promoting screening, aiming to reduce cervical cancer incidence and mortality rates in Nairobi and similar settings. Methods: Descriptive cross-sectional study design was used. Stratified random sampling and simple random sampling methods were used. Sample size was 363 CHVs. Data collection involved collection of primary data using a self-administered questionnaire and FGDS. Data analysis was carried out through both descriptive statistics and inferential analysis. Findings were presented in percentages, pie charts. Results: Results indicated that while CHVs can play critical role in counselling women on importance of cervical- cancer screening, significant proportion of respondents had not counselled women on this topic. Similarly, while referrals are an important aspect of promoting cervical-cancer screening, majority of respondents did not refer cases of cervical-cancer screening to other CHVs. Conclusions: Study identified significant social, economic, and cultural barriers that influence cervical cancer screening participation among women. It revealed these barriers affect how CHVs promote screening. Furthermore, considerable health system obstacles hinder effective promotion of this crucial preventive measure. Keywords: CHVs, Cervical cancer screening, Women of reproductive age
INTRODUCTION
Cervical-cancer is the fourth common type of cancer among women and is estimated to affect 572,624 new cases each year.1 85% of cervical-cancer burden globally is found in developing nations and contributes to 7.9% of all cancers in women.2 Worldwide 7.5% of all deaths result from cervical cancer in women.3 The mortality rate is found to be high in regions that underutilize or have limited screening and treatment services.4
Cancer of the cervix can be prevented. On the contrary, it has been found to be the major cause of women death in Africa. Every year in African countries, cervical-cancer is found to account for 22% of all cases of female cancers and about 12% of all cancer cases that are newly diagnosed. Further, out of every 100000 women, 25 women are diagnosed with cancer of the cervix and out of these about 23 dies from the disease every year in Africa.5 Most of these women get diagnosed when the cancer is at its advanced stage as a result of poor outcomes in early tests. Therefore, cervical-cancer has remained to be the
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2385
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
most common cancer among women in Eastern Africa and Central Africa.6
In Kenya however, the case of cervical-cancer is becoming a threat for the survival of women as the number of new cervical-cancer cases equal the number of deaths indicating that close to all women who get cancer die of the same disease. This disease burden implies that women are likely to die of cervical-cancer. In every week, about fifteen new cases of cervical-cancer are reported in Nairobi.7,8 For girls, cervical-cancer can be prevented through vaccination and the disease can be treated successfully if detected early. Considerable efforts have been made in the last 15 years to get better alterative screening services for cervical-cancer for settings with minimal resources. Such alternatives include Visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) since it requires a little training and can be conducted by physicians, nurses, or midwives. Treatments for detected abnormalities are provided during the screening visit which eliminates the need for multiple visits to health facilities.
In developed nations, the participation of CHVs in promoting the uptake of cervical cancer screening is high. Previous study showed that CHVs in developed nations are actively involved in enlightening women concerning early cervical cancer screening to detect premalignant lesions and ensure that proper management is implemented early to prevent development, to reduce the disease.9
In African countries the participation of CHVs in promoting the uptake of cervical cancer screening is above average despite the fact that they face various challenges. These include inadequate facilities for their work and low government support. Previous studies have showed that over 60% of community health workers in Africa work as volunteers, and that CHVs are actively involved in sharing with women on the government interventions aimed at enhancing knowledge of cervical cancer and promoting screening intentions and uptake among ethnic minority women.10,11
Objectives
Main objective
Main objectives were to investigate the role of CHVs in the uptake of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age in Nairobi, Kenya.
Specific objectives
Specific objectives were to determine the roles of CHVs in promoting the uptake of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age in Nairobi, Kenya, to assess the barriers for the participation of CHVs who play a role in cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age in Nairobi, Kenya and to determine the effects of health and community systems barriers on the
level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age in Nairobi, Kenya.
METHODS
Study used descriptive cross sectional study design to describe role of CHVs in cervical-cancer screenings. Because cervical-cancer screening is carried out in health facilities. Study was facility based.
Study was in Nairobi from October, 2018 to January 2019. All selected (CHUs) linked health units in Nairobi were involved. Nairobi consists of people with varying ages, level of education, marital status, religion and economic status. Youths make up largest percentage of population in Nairobi. Christianity accounts to 84.8% of residents with remaining percentage of Muslim, Baha'i, Buddhism, Hinduism and traditional religions.
Community health units representing 17 CHUs in Nairobi was the target population. CHVs who operate in selected community health centers formed the unit of study. Kenya master health facility list estimates that each CHU carries about 50 CHVs. Since all sub-counties have more than 1 CHU, and each have 50CHV’s (130CHU’s X 50CHV’s), this gave study population to be 6,500. Respondents were CHVs who operate in selected CHUs.
To ensure all 17 sub-counties in Nairobi were well represented, study employed stratified random sampling while simple random sampling technique allowed for selection of individual CHUs and a census of all CHVs from selected sub-counties. This gave sample of 363. Stratified random sampling ensured that all parts of population were represented in the sample and which helped increase efficiency in estimation that is error of estimation. Sub counties formed the strata. Population was first categorized into strata with each stratum having similar characteristic. Sample was then obtained from each stratum which was pre-specified.
Fisher formula was employed in getting the sample. Fisher formula was,
𝑧2𝑝(1 −𝑝) 𝑛=
2 𝑑
Where;
N is sample size
z is value for standard normal deviate for level of confidence set at 95% for this study whose value is 1.96.
d is level of precision at 0.05 for CI at 95%
p is proportion to be estimated, which for this study was 0.5.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2386
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
0.5 was used since this is proportion in target population estimated to have characteristic of interest the researcher.
Sample size was therefore arrived at as
(1.962)(0.5)(1 −0.5)
2 (0.05)
𝑛=
𝑛= 384
N=6,500, total population size
However, since population was less than 10,000, Cochran formula was used to adjust sample size further.
informed consent was obtained from each participant before conducting the interviews.
RESULTS
Roles of CHVs in promoting uptake of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age, counselling and referrals
Respondents were asked to indicate whether they have counselled women of reproductive on uptake of cervical- cancer screening. Results in Table 1 showed majority (78%) indicated they had not counselled women of reproductive on uptake of cervical-cancer screening while remaining (22%) indicated that they had counselled women of reproductive on uptake of cervical-cancer screening.
n0 = n/(1+ ((n -1)/ N))
n0 = 384/ (1+ ((384 -1)/ 6,500))
n0=363, desired sample size
The study included CHVs who gave informed consent to participate in study, CHVs who had been operating in the region for at least one year and CHVs who were of eligible group for cervical-cancer screening and reporting to the selected health centres. The study excluded CHVs who met inclusion criteria but were sick at time of study.
Data Analysis involved descriptive statistical analysis which used percentages to describe variables under study and results presented in form of bar charts and frequency tables. Qualitative data on the other hand was analyzed thematically. Inferential statistics involved chi square and logistic regression analysis. Statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) was used to conduct descriptive as well as inferential statistics. Chi square and logistic regression were used to achieve objectives.
Ethical clearance was granted by Kenyatta University ethical review committee, Kenya while the national commission for science, technology and innovation, Kenya provided the research permit to conduct the study in Nairobi County, and Nairobi City County health service provided an authorization letter and a written
Respondents asked to indicate whether they refer to other CHVs’ cases of cervical-cancer screening. Results in Table 1 indicated that majority of respondents (78%) did not refer to other CHV cases of cervical-cancer screening.
Table 1: Counselling and referrals.
Social economic barriers and level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age
Chi square findings indicated a significant relationship between income level and participation level (ꭓ2=19.539; p=0.000). Chi square findings indicated a significant relationship between transport expenses and participation level ꭓ2=38.225, p=0.000). Chi square findings indicated a significant relationship between daily expenses and participation level (x2=5.9; p=0.05). Results were in line with Mupepi et al who asserted that socio-economic impact of cervical-cancer is considerable and has negative consequences in participation on promotion of uptake of cervical cancer screening among women.12
Table 2: Social economic barriers and level of participation.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2387
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
Odd ratio regression between social economic barriers and level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age
Odds of high participation are 2.870 times higher for those with income as renumeration compared to those who did not receive income as volunteers (Odds=2.870, p=0.001). Extent of ability to cater for transport expenses is significant predictor for participation levels (p=0.000). Odds of high participation are for 3.754 higher for those who indicated that they are able to afford transport cost to a higher extent as compared to those who indicated to a low extent. Extent of ability to cater for daily expenses is significant predictor for the participation levels (p=0.000).
Social cultural barriers and level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age in Nairobi County, Kenya
Chi square findings indicated significant relationship between Appreciation by community and level of participation by CHVs (x2=92.26; p=0.000). Chi square findings indicated significant relationship between churches support and level of participation by CHVs (x2=2.88; p=0.000). Results were in line with Ndejjo et al who investigated the community-based factors that influence cervical cancer screening uptake in rural Uganda. Study found that lack of social support and community stigma associated with cervical cancer were significant barriers to screening uptake among women in rural Uganda.13
Odd ratio regression between social cultural barriers and level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age
Odds of high participation are 1.127 times higher for those who indicated to a moderate extent that they are appreciated by their community for promoting the uptake of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age as compared to those who indicated low extent, (Odds=1.127, p=0.000). Odds of high participation are 2.112 higher for those who indicated to a higher extent that they are appreciated by their community for promoting the uptake of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age as compared to those who indicated moderate extent (Odds=2.112, p=0.000).
View of CHVs’ job in promoting uptake of cervical- cancer screening among women of reproductive as productive was a significant predictor for participation levels (p=0.000). Odds of high participation are 4.190 times higher for those who indicated to a moderate extent that they viewed work of the CHVs in promoting uptake
of cervical cancer screening among women of the reproductive as productive as compared to those who indicated the high extent, (Odds=4.190, p=0.000). Local Churches supportive of the CHVs who promoting uptake of the cervical-cancer screening among women is significant predictor for the participation levels (p=0.000).
Health system barriers as well as the level of the participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical- cancer screening among women of the reproductive age
Chi square findings indicated significant relationship between the health system barriers as well as the level of the participation (x2=26.354, p=0.000; x2=61.061, p=0.000; x2=79.763, p=0.000; x2=76.856, p=0.000 and x2=58.762, p=0.000). Results were in line with Ogbuanu et al who investigated the impact of health system factors on the utilization of cervical cancer screening services among immigrant women in the United States. Study found that lack of the health insurance as well as the limited access to healthcare services were significant barriers to the screening utilization among the immigrant women.10
Odd ratio regression between health system barriers and level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age
Odd ratio results indicated that availability of training on the promotion of the cervical cancer screening is significant predictor for the participation levels (p=0.047). Odd ratio results indicated that availability of CHV training manual is significant predictor for participation levels (p=0.008). Odd ratio results indicated that availability of screening services is significant predictor for participation levels (p=0.001). Odd ratio results indicated that accessibility of health system programs is significant predictor for participation levels (p=0.000).
Socio-demographic barriers and level of participation of CHVs in enhancing the use of cervical-cancer screening among women of reproductive age
Chi square findings indicated an insignificant relationship between social demographic barriers and level of the participation (x2=0.941, p=0.815; x2=4.871, p=0.181; x2=7.18, p=0.127). Results did not agree with Mwaka et al who aimed to investigate the socio-demographic factors associated with the cervical cancer screening in the Sub-Saharan Africa as well as the study found that older age, higher education level, higher household wealth, urban residence as well as the having had multiple sexual partners were significant predictors of cervical cancer screening uptake among women in sub- Saharan Africa.9
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2388
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
Table 3: Odd ratio.
a. Variable(s) entered on step 1: Renumeration, transport expenses, and daily expenses.
Table 4: Social Cultural Barriers and level of participation.
Table 5: Odd ratio.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2389
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
Table 6: Association between health system factors and level of participation in promotion of cervical cancer
screening.
Table 7: Odd ratio.
a. Variable(s) entered on step 1: Availability of training on promotion of cervical cancer screening, availability of CHV training manual, availability of screening services, accessible health system programs, skilled and competent health workers.
Table 8: Cross tabulation.
Continued.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2390
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
DISCUSSION
The results indicate that while CHVs can play a critical role in counselling women on the importance of cervical- cancer screening, a significant proportion of respondents had not counselled women on this topic. The majority of respondents did not refer cases of cervical-cancer screening. The majority of the respondents were not receiving remuneration, and a significant proportion of them found it difficult to cater for their transport and daily expenses. Furthermore, given the significant relationship between transport expenses, daily expenses, and participation, interventions aimed at providing support for CHVs to cater for their transport and daily expenses could be beneficial in enhancing their participation. The results showed that a significant number of CHVs were not appreciated enough by the community and local churches were not supportive of CHVs' work, which affected their participation levels. Similarly, local churches' support to CHVs was a significant predictor of participation levels. Findings suggest that social-cultural barriers significantly affect the participation of CHVs in promoting cervical cancer screening uptake in Nairobi. The results indicated that health system barriers that hindered the effective promotion of cervical cancer screening, including lack of availability of training, CHV training manuals, screening services, accessible health system programs, skilled and competent health workers. This finding supports previous research that has shown that health system factors such as lack of health insurance and limited access to healthcare services are significant barriers to screening utilization among women.14
The study investigated the relationship between socio- demographic barriers and participation level of (CHVs).
The findings indicated that there was no significant relationship between socio-demographic barriers (age, level of education, and duration of service) and the level of participation. This suggests that socio-demographic factors may not be barriers to CHV participation. The results are not consistent with the previous study, which found that older age, higher education level, higher household wealth, urban residence, and having had multiple sexual partners were significant predictors of cervical cancer screening uptake among women in sub- Saharan Africa. However, it is important to note that the present study was focused on the level of participation of CHVs, rather than individual predictors of screening uptake among women.15,16
CONCLUSION
Study concluded that social economic barriers, social cultural barriers and health system barriers significantly influences participation level of CHVs as this confirmed by study participants and that social demographic barriers do not affect level of participation. Addressing these barriers to enhance role of CHVs could motivate them to participate more actively in promoting cervical cancer screening. Additionally, policies that support CHVs participation level could enhance their participation.
Funding: No funding sources Conflict of interest: None declared Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
1. International Agency for Research on Cancer. Cervical cancer estimated incidence, mortality and
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2391
Ojwang NM et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2023 Jul;10(7):2385-2392
prevalence worldwide in 2018. World Health Organization. 2018. 2. Bruni L, Barrionuevo-Rosas L, Albero G, Aldea M, Serrano B, Valencia B. Human papillomavirus and related diseases report. L'Hospitalet de Llobregat: ICO Information Centre on HPV and Cancer. 2017. 3. Bray F, Ferlay J, Soerjomataram I, Siegel RL, Torre LA, Jemal A. Global cancer statistics 2018: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and mortality worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries. CA: a cancer J Clin. 2018;68(6):394-424. 4. Naanyu V, Asiki G, Wachira J, Bashir A, Nyabuto E, Chitekwe S. Exploring the Roles of Community Health Workers in Facilitating Access to Cervical Cancer Screening Services for Women in Rural Kenya. BMC Health Services Res. 2020;20(1):1-10. 5. Liu F, Li S, Liang J, Li H, Li J, Zhang J, Li X. Exploring the Role of Village Doctors in Promoting Cervical Cancer Screening in Rural China. BMC Public Health. 2021;21(1):1-12. 6. Othman SS, Ahmed FH, Mohamad NI, Ahmad F. Exploring the Role of Community Health Volunteers in Promoting Cervical Cancer Screening in Low-and Middle-Income Countries: A Scoping Review. Frontiers in Public Health. 2021;9:1-12. 7. Korir A, Gakunga R, Subramanian SV, Okerosi N, Cheserem E, Omenge OR. Understanding barriers to cervical cancer screening among women in Kenya: a qualitative study. BMC Women's Health. 2020;20(1):69. 8. Mupepi SC, Sampselle CM, Johnson TR. Knowledge, attitudes, and demographic factors influencing cervical cancer screening behavior of Zimbabwean women. J Community Health. 2019;44(1):25-34.
9. Mwaka AD, Okello ES, Wabinga HR. Perceptions and attitudes of women towards cervical cancer screening and vaccination in Uganda. BMC Women's Health. 2018;18(1):71. 10. Ogbuanu C, Morhason-Bello I, Okonofua F. Knowledge, attitude, and practices related to cervical cancer prevention and screening among Nigerian women: a narrative review of the literature. J Cancer Education. 2018;33(2):269-76. 11. Abotchie PN, Shokar NK. Cervical cancer screening among college students in ghana: knowledge and health beliefs. Int J Gynecological Cancer, 2017;27(9):1825-31. 12. Owoyemi JO, Efuntoye OA, Fagbolade MO. Factors associated with the uptake of cervical cancer screening among women in Ilorin, North Central Nigeria: A hospital-based study. J Cancer Policy. 2019;20:100-7. 13. Ndejjo R, Mukama T, Kiguli J, Musoke D. Knowledge, facilitators and barriers to cervical cancer screening among women in Uganda: a qualitative study. BMJ Open. 2016;6(4):e010435. 14. Rajbhandari P, Pradhananga K, Sharma A, Shrestha B. Knowledge, attitude, and practice on cervical cancer screening among women attending outpatient department of a hospital in Kathmandu, Nepal. J Oncol. 2019;1-7.
Cite this article as: Ojwang NM, Keraka MN, Mugo JM. Role of community health volunteers in promoting uptake of cervical cancer screening among women of reproductive age, Nairobi City, Kenya. Int J Community Med Public Health 2023;10:2385-92.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | July 2023 | Vol 10 | Issue 7 Page 2392