Original Research Article
An evaluation study of behavioural management technique-thaumaturgy, live modeling and tell show do
Department of Pediatric and Preventive Dentistry, College of Dental Sciences, Davangere, Karnataka, India
Received: 15 March 2023
Revised: 13 April 2023
Accepted: 18 April 2023
*Correspondence:
Dr. Srinivas Y. Naidu,
E-mail: srinu12nov1995@gmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: The aim of behavior management is to instill a positive dental attitude in the anxious patient. It is the means by which the dental team can effectively and efficiently perform treatment, and encourages a child to have a long-term interest in improving dental health and the ongoing prevention of disease. Aim of the study was to evaluate the behavior of the children by using various behavior management techniques like thaumaturgy, live modelling and tell show do.
Method: A total of 120 children, aged between 5-6 years fulfilling eligibility criteria were taken for the study. three groups were made and comparison was done between three behaviour management techniques: thaumaturgy, live modelling and tell show do. behaviour was recorded using Frankel behaviour rating scale was recorded before and after the procedure.
Results: there was significant difference between thaumaturgy and other behaviour management techniques live modelling and tell show do (p=0.005). there was no statistical change in the behaviour between tell show do and live modelling.
Conclusions: Thaumaturgy technique is better at reducing anxiety levels and all the three behaviour management techniques were effective in installing positive behaviour.
Keywords: Tell show do, Live modelling, Behaviour management, Thaumaturgy
INTRODUCTION
The most difficult challenge a dentist faces when treating a paediatric patient is uncooperative behaviour caused by anxiety or fear. A dentist must consider not only the nature and severity of dental disease, but also the interactions between the child, his or her parents, and the clinician.1
The goal of behaviour management is to instill in the anxious patient a positive dental attitude. It allows the dental team to perform treatment more effectively and efficiently, and it encourages a child to have a long-term interest in improving dental health and disease prevention.2
Basic behaviour guidance is dependent on four factors: Status of dental disease, mental and physical development of child and parenteral characteristics.
Dentist’s personality and capabilities1
Thaumaturgy: It is a new technique used to manage strong-willed children. Thaumaturgy is a tool that helps the dentist perform necessary treatment by distracting and relaxing the child. The thaumaturgic techniques are tailored to a specific cognitive age group.
Thumb and light trick: Two thumb sleeves incorporating a lighting device will be worn on the operator's thumb, which can be activated/deactivated at the operator's discretion. To keep the subject's interest, various creative hand movements will be performed (Figure 1).
Book trick: To maintain the subject's interest and negotiate with the subject's reasoning capability, a colouring book with blank pages, black and white images, and coloured images sequentially on the same leaf will be displayed to the subject.
Item trick: In front of the subject, six different items (child-safe toys) will be displayed. Before the game, the subject is given a cue card with the name of one of the items. The item elimination formula will be used to eliminate one of the items in each round of the game until only one item remains, which is the item on the cue card.3
Tell show do: Technique is a simple and easy technique where the procedure is explained to the child.
Tell means explain the procedure to the child. Show means showing the equipments used for the procedure and do means doing the procedure on the child.4
Live modelling is a behaviour management technique, where the child is allowed to observe one or more individuals (models). The main idea behind the live modeling is that a child’s behavior can be modified by simply observing another child who is cooperatively receiving the same treatment.5
Thus, present study aims to evaluate behavior of children by using various behavior management techniques like thaumaturgy, live modelling and tell show do.
Materials and methodology
This study was conducted in department of pediatric and preventive dentistry, college of dental sciences, davangere, Karnataka. Ethical clearance was obtained from institutional review board of the college for the study.
Type of the study was in vivo comparative study.
Study duration from January-April 2022.
Selection criteria
Inclusion criteria
Children of age 5-6 years of age, healthy children with no systemic illness, allergies etc., children requiring dental treatment and children with proper parental/guardian/patient consent were included in study.
Exclusion criteria
Children who need special care excluded from study.
Study subjects
Group A: Thaumaturgy, group B: Live modelling and group C: Tell show do.
This is an in vivo evaluation study containing 120 children aged between 5-6 years. Children were selected according to inclusion criteria. The study was performed by a single operator at the department of pediatric and Preventive dentistry. The consent from the parent/guardian of the child along with a verbal consent from the child was obtained. The children were randomnly divided into three groups. Frankel behaviour rating scale was recorded
Definitely negative (--), negative (-), positive (+), definitely positive (++)
Group A: Thaumaturgy
The thumb and light trick consist of a pair of thumb sleeves which is incorporated with light which can be activated and deactivated at operators will. Children in thaumaturgy group thumb and light trick was used where, two thumb sleeves were worn on the operator's thumb, and Several hand movements were performed in front of children to sustain the children interest. Behaviour was recorded using Frankel behaviour rating scale was recorded after the procedure (Figure 1-3).5
Group B: Live modelling
Children in this group were made to observe the live models undergoing treatment. The live models can be siblings, parents or patients in the dental set up. Behaviour was recorded using Frankel behaviour rating scale was recorded after the procedure (Figure 4).
Group C: Tell show do
Tell: The procedure was explained to children (Figure 5).
Show: The procedure was shown to children (Figure 6).
Do: Then procedure was done to children (Figure 7).6,7
Behaviour was recorded using Frankel behaviour rating scale was recorded after the procedure.6,7
The data obtained was subjected to statistical analysis. The results were determined using chi-square test, unpaired t test and ANOVA test. A p value less than 0.05 was considered as statistically significant. The data was subjected to statistical analysis using SPSS 21.0 software.
RESULTS
Result obtained along with statistical analysis has been explained under the section of tables. Detailed explanation of each table and graph have been described below. So, the results of study were tabulated and analysed under following headings.
Table 1 shows the scores of Frankel behaviour rating scale before the intervention, Table 2, shows the scores of Frankel behaviour rating scale after intervention, Table 3 shows intergroup comparison by using Kruskal Walis test, Table 4, shows intragroup comparison within the thaumaturgy group, Table 5, shows intragroup comparison within the live modelling group, Table 6 shows intragroup comparison within the tell show do group. The Table 4-6 represents intragroup comparison by using Wilcoxon test.
Explains mean percentage of Frankel behaviour rating scale before the intervention. Out of 120 children, 43.5% children were from negative followed by 28.3% definitely negative, 23.9% positive and 4.3% definitely positive.
Explains the change of behaviour after intervention by Frankel behaviour rating scale. In group A i.e., thaumaturgy-out of 40 children 63.33% showed definitely positive behaviour followed by 33.3% positive behaviour and 3.3% negative behaviour. In group B i.e., live modelling out of 40 children 54.8% showed positive behaviour followed by 25.8% definitely positive and 6% negative behaviour. In group C i.e., 54.8% positive followed by 22.6% both positive behaviour.
This table explains the intergroup comparison between all the three group before and after intervention through Kruskal Walis test. The mean ranks obtained was higher for group A (60.23) followed by live modelling (40.95) and tell show do (38.76). P=0.001 which was less than 0.005 indicating that this study was statistically significant and group A i.e., thaumaturgy group was more effective at installing positive behaviour in children compared to live modelling and tell show do groups. Comparison between live modelling and tell show do groups showed statistically non-significant. Indicating that live modelling and tell show do behaviour management techniques were equally effective at installing positive behaviour in children.
Intragroup comparison
Table 4 explains the intragroup comparison of Frankel behaviour rating scale before and after intervention in the group A i.e., Thaumaturgy group. The p value obtained was less than 0.005 showing that the statistically significant.
Table 5, explains the intragroup comparison of Frankel behaviour rating scale before and after intervention in the group B i.e., live modelling group. The p value obtained was less than 0.005 showing that the statistically significant.
Table 6, explains the intragroup comparison of Frankel behaviour rating scale before and after in the group C i.e., Tell show do. The p value obtained was less than 0.005 showing that statistically significant.
All the three groups showed statistically significant (p>0.005) indicating that all the three behaviour management techniques installed positive behaviour in children.
a. Kruskal Wallis test, b. Grouping variable: group.
a. FBRS after<FBRS before, b. FBRS after>FBRS before, c. FBRS after=FBRS before. A. Wilcoxon signed ranks test. B. Based on negative ranks.
a. FBRS after <FBRS before, b. FBRS after >FBRS before, c. FBRS after=FBRS before. a. Wilcoxon Signed ranks test, b. Based on negative ranks.
a. FBRS after < FBRS before, b. FBRS after > FBRS before, c. FBRS after = FBRS before, a. Wilcoxon Signed ranks test, b. Based on negative ranks.
DISCUSSION
Dental and medical procedures are often invasive and generate considerable anxiety for children. For over 30 years there has been recognition of the need to help children cope. Behaviour-management problems are the most important reasons why children are referred to the specialized paediatric dentist.8
Despite greater advancements in dentistry in terms of techniques, technology, and materials, anxiety connected to the dental environment and specific operations is a large and prevalent problem faced by child patients around the world, and is regarded as a serious public health concern. A stumbling block in the delivery of high-quality dental treatment.9
Dental fear and anxiety can have psychologic, cognitive, and behavioral effects in children. The behaviour, which is focused on the child's level of cooperation during dental treatment, appears to be influenced by a variety of factors, including mental development, temperament, and parental involvement. as well as previous experiences.10
For children, dental operations are a typical source of pain and suffering. The identification of behaviours that indicate anxiety during dental treatment, as well as the use of anxiety and pain perception management strategies, combined with the establishment of a trust relationship between the child, the family, and the health care professional, can all contribute to positive treatment experiences.10 The child management behaviour in paediatric clinic is the way by which the dental health care team effectively and efficiently performs treatment for a child. The aim is to establish a positive dental attitude as it is important for all behaviour management techniques.11
Frankel in 1962 gave behaviour rating scale which is most commonly used in the studies. He gave definitely negative, negative, positive and definitely positive based on the behaviour of the children. Wright in 1975 gave modification for Frankel behaviour rating scale by adding symbols to the ratings. (--), (-), (+), (++) for definitely negative, negative, positive and definitely positive respectively.12
This study was done to evaluate the new behaviour management technique that is thaumaturgy by comparing with live modelling and tell show do. Isaac Bonewits defined thaumaturgy as the use of magic for non-religious purposes; the art and science of wonder working.6
In this study age group 5-6 years were taken. In thaumaturgy group, thumb and light trick was used, contains thumb sleeves which was incorporated with lights. Various hand movements were performed. Children of this age imagined light appearing and disappearing as a magical phenomenon. When the dental procedures were completed, the thaumaturgic effect had the child pondering the trick. These tricks taught the subjects to cooperate.
Peretz and Gluck used a magic book for noninvasive dental examination procedures to assess behaviour modification in children aged 3 to 6 years. The Frankel rating scale was used to quantify anxiety.9
In contrast to that sapna konde et al three thaumaturgic techniques were used at three different stages of cognition; more reliable subjective assessment tools were employed for the quantification of anxiety. Children belonging to age group involving 2- 7 years, 7-11 years and 11-13 years. In 2-7 years children, thumb and light trick and magic trick was effective, 7-11 years- magic trick and item trick and 11-13 years item trick was effective.6
Live modelling is a technique where children are made to observe live models like siblings, parents or children who are undergoing treatment. Tell show do is technique where the procedure was explained, shown and done on the children. Both these behaviour management techniques were successful at installing positive behaviour and also bring change in the behaviour of children.
In this study thaumaturgy was compared to live modelling and tell show do. Thaumaturgy was better compared to live modelling and tell show. Live modelling and tell show were equally effective. Farhat et al compared live modelling and tell show do. Results obtained were live modelling was better at reducing anxiety in children when compared to tell show do.7
Saurabh et al assessed anxiety and fear by comparing live modeling and tell show by measuring heart rates.13 Children who participated in live modelling with their parents as models had lower heart rates than those who participated in live modelling with their siblings as models or those who were prepared using the tell-show-do method.
Virupaxi compared filmed modelling and tell show do behaviour management techniques by measuring heart rates. And study concluded that both the techniques were equally effective in reducing anxiety in children.14
Priyanka et al assessed anxiety levels by comparing tell show do, live modelling and filmed modelling by measuring heart levels and facial image scale.15 Study concluded that modelling is better than tell show do.
Radhakrishna et al did a study in which anxiety levels were assessed by comparing tell show play do, smart phone game and tell show do, concluded that tell show play do and smart phone was better at reducing anxiety levels in children.16
Thus, according to our study, Thaumaturgic techniques have proven to be effective in managing the behaviour of children of all ages. In conventional paediatric care, thaumaturgy is used as the sole method of behaviour management. Thaumaturgic techniques can be used to control and convert negative behavioural patterns to more desirable behavioural patterns using both invasive and noninvasive manoeuvres. Thaumaturgy has been shown to be a novel behaviour shaping technique that can improve the clinical outcome of dental treatment regardless of the child's attitude toward dental procedures.
Limitation of the study is that only one behaviour assessment scale was used. various subjective and objective parameters could have been considered.
CONCLUSION
This study was done to compare the three behaviour management techniques-thaumaturgy, live modelling and tell show do. The study concluded that Thaumaturgy technique is better at reducing anxiety levels and also effective in bringing positive behaviour in children. Thaumaturgy, live modelling and tell show do were effective in installing positive behaviour. The choice of behaviour management technique plays vital role in managing the children in pediatric clinic and also helps in the ease of treatment.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee
REFERENCES
- 1. Jain V, Sarkar S, Saha S, Haldar S. Basic behaviour guidance factors and techniques for effective child management in dental clinic-an update review. Int J Oral Health Med Res. 2016;2(6):177-82.
- 2. Gupta A, Marya CM, Bhatia HP, Dahiya V. Behaviour management of an anxious child. Stomatologija. 2014;16(1):3-6.
- 3. Konde S, Sumaiyya S, Agarwal M, Peethambar P. “Thaumaturgy”-A Novel Behavior-shaping Technique. Int J Clin Pediatr Dentistr. 2020;13(4):318.
- 4. Zhu M, Yu H, Xie B, Li H, He Q, Li H et al. Experiential learning for children’s dental anxiety: a cluster randomized trial. BMC Oral Health. 2020;20(1):1-8.
- 5. Yassin MS. Evaluation of Live Modelling and Filmed Modelling Techniques versus No Modelling on Child Anxiety during Dental Treatment: A Randomized Clinical Trial. CU Theses. 2020.
- 6. Peretz B, Gluck G. Magic trick: A behavioural strategy for the management of strong‐willed children. Int J Paediatr Dentistr. 2005;15(6):429-36.
- 7. Farhat-McHayleh N, Harfouche A, Souaid P. Techniques for managing behaviour in pediatric dentistry: comparative study of live modelling and tell-show-do based on children's heart rates during treatment. J Canadian Dental Asso. 2009;75(4).
- 8. Weinstein P, Raadal M, Naidu S, Yoshida T, Kvale G, Milgrom P. A videotaped intervention to enhance child control and reduce anxiety of the pain of dental injections. Eur J Paediatr Dentistr. 2003;4(4):181-5.
- 9. Navit S, Johri N, Khan SA, Singh RK, Chadha D, Navit P et al. Effectiveness and comparison of various audio distraction aids in management of anxious dental paediatric patients. JCDR. 2015;9(12):5-9.
- 10. Goettems ML, Zborowski EJ, Dos Santos Costa F, Costa VP, Torriani DD. Nonpharmacologic intervention on the prevention of pain and anxiety during pediatric dental care: a systematic review. Academic Pediatr. 2017;17(2):110-9.
- 11. Chandrapooja J, Selvarasu K. Behavioural management techniques in pediatric clinic. Int J Pharm Bio Sci. 2016;6:10-5.
- 12. Riba H, Al-Zahrani S, Al-Buqmi N, Al-Jundi A. A review of behavior evaluation scales in pediatric dentistry and suggested modification to the Frankl scale. EC Dent Sci. 2017;16(6):269-75.
- 13. Saurabh T, Ruchi A. Behaviour Management Techniques in Paediatric Dentistry; Comparative study based on heart rate Between Live Modelling and Tell–Show-Do. Medicine. 2016;1.
- 14. Virupaxi SG. A comparative study of filmed modelling and tell-show-do technique on anxiety in children undergoing dental treatment. Indian J Dental Advancements. 2016;8(4):215-22.
- 15. Karekar P, Bijle MN, Walimbe H. Effect of three behavior guidance techniques on anxiety indicators of children undergoing diagnosis and preventive dental care. J Clin Pediatr Dentistr. 2019;43(3):167-72
- 16. Alnamankany A. Video modelling and dental anxiety in children. A randomised clinical trial. Eur J Paediatr Dentistr. 2019;20(3):242-6.